Andy Mitten Reveals Why Ruben Amorim Has Stayed Silent After Manchester United Exit
The former United boss has said nothing since his January departure – and now the real reason has finally come out
Manchester United’s decision to part ways with Ruben Amorim so early in 2026 sent shockwaves through the club and its fanbase. The move came just days into the new year and marked a sudden end to a 14-month spell that promised much but ultimately delivered little of the progress supporters had hoped for. Since his exit, however, one thing has stood out almost as much as the sacking itself: Amorim’s silence.
While Manchester United have quietly rebuilt momentum under interim boss Michael Carrick, their former manager has said nothing publicly. No farewell message. No interview. No social media post thanking the fans or explaining his side of the story. For a club where managers’ exits are often followed by statements, videos or emotional reflections, the lack of communication has felt strange. Now, respected journalist Andy Mitten has shed light on why Amorim has chosen to stay quiet.
Speaking on Off The Ball, Mitten explained that the silence is not down to bitterness, legal restrictions or behind-the-scenes drama. Instead, it appears to be deeply personal. Mitten revealed that he reached out to people close to Amorim to understand the situation better.
“I got in contact, not with him, but I know all the people around him,” Mitten said. “And I’m like, why is he not saying anything? And they’re just like, ‘That’s just Ruben.’”
According to those within Amorim’s inner circle, the former United boss is simply not the type to make public statements when things go wrong. It is part of his character. He prefers to process disappointment privately rather than address it in front of cameras or on social media. However, Mitten was clear that this approach may not sit well with everyone at Old Trafford.
“He should,” Mitten added. “People who paid his wages and supported him massively deserve that.”
The contrast with previous Manchester United managers could not be clearer. Mitten pointed to David Moyes, who was sacked in 2014 after a difficult season. Despite the pain of losing his job, Moyes still made sure to acknowledge the fans.
“When David Moyes left Manchester United, that day I got a text message,” Mitten recalled. “There was no WhatsApp then. Andy, can you just thank the fans on my behalf? There’s nothing polished about it. And it was someone who was hurting.”
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, meanwhile, went in the opposite direction. His emotional farewell video after leaving United was widely shared and warmly received by supporters. While some felt it was overly produced, many fans appreciated the honesty and gratitude it showed.
The comparison highlights why Amorim’s silence has divided opinion. Some supporters feel let down, believing a simple message of thanks would have gone a long way after more than a year in charge. Others are more understanding, pointing out that not every manager handles exits in the same way, especially when the experience has been difficult.
And difficult it was. Amorim arrived with a strong reputation, but his time at Old Trafford never truly clicked. Performances were inconsistent, confidence drained from key players, and United often looked unsure of their identity on the pitch. By the time the decision was made to part ways, many fans felt it was the right call, even if the manner and timing raised eyebrows.
Since then, the mood around the club has shifted noticeably. After a brief caretaker spell from Darren Fletcher, Michael Carrick has stepped in and delivered instant stability. United are unbeaten in five matches under Carrick, winning four and drawing their latest game away at West Ham. The team looks more organised, more confident and, perhaps most importantly, more united.
That resurgence has helped soften the focus on Amorim’s absence from the public eye. United now sit fourth in the Premier League table and are firmly in the race for a top-five finish, which could be enough to secure Champions League football. For a season that once looked destined to drift into disappointment, there is now real hope.
In that context, Amorim’s silence feels less important with each passing week. Fans are more interested in what lies ahead than what has already gone wrong. Carrick has brought clarity and calm, and players who struggled under the previous regime are beginning to show their true quality again.
Still, Amorim’s United spell will be remembered as a missed opportunity. The talent was there, but the connection never fully formed. Whether he eventually chooses to speak about his time at Old Trafford remains to be seen. For now, as Andy Mitten suggests, the silence is simply who Ruben Amorim is.
And at Manchester United, with momentum finally building again, the focus has moved on. The past 14 months may have been frustrating, but the future suddenly looks far brighter.
