Oklahoma didn’t just dominate college softball—they rewrote the rules. From jaw-dropping home runs to clutch strikeouts that silenced entire stadiums, these Sooner legends didn’t just play the game—they changed it.
When it comes to college softball, few programs can boast the kind of sustained excellence that the University of Oklahoma has achieved. The Sooners have transformed softball into a powerhouse sport, dominating the NCAA landscape with multiple national championships and a legacy that continues to grow. This legacy isn’t just about teams; it’s about the incredible players who have donned the crimson and cream over the decades. Each brought their unique blend of talent, grit, and heart, elevating Oklahoma softball to legendary status. Today, we’re counting down the 10 greatest Oklahoma softball players to ever wear the jersey—a list that spans eras, positions, and moments that changed the game forever. Brace yourself, because #1 will give you chills.
Starting off the list, you have to acknowledge Keilani Ricketts, a name synonymous with dominance. Ricketts was a force of nature during her time at Oklahoma, combining power, precision, and an unyielding competitive spirit that left opponents in awe. As a pitcher, her fastball and changeup were nearly unhittable, but she wasn’t just a one-trick pony. Her prowess at the plate added a lethal edge, making her a two-way threat who could change the course of any game. Ricketts racked up accolades, including two USA Softball Collegiate Player of the Year awards, and led the Sooners to a national championship in 2013. Watching her on the field was witnessing softball artistry at its finest.
Next up is Jennifer Stewart, who brought consistency and calm leadership to the infield. Stewart’s defensive skills were unmatched; her quick reflexes and precise throws saved countless runs and anchored the Sooners’ defense through some of their toughest seasons. But what truly set Stewart apart was her ability to rise to the occasion in clutch moments. Whether it was a game-saving double play or a timely hit, Stewart’s presence was a steadying force that teammates and coaches revered. Her tenure helped solidify Oklahoma’s reputation as a program that excels not just offensively but defensively.
Then there’s Lauren Chamberlain, the prodigious slugger whose bat seemed to write its own story. Chamberlain redefined power hitting for Oklahoma, shattering records with her home runs and RBIs. She wasn’t just powerful; she was smart, disciplined, and fearless at the plate. Chamberlain’s personality lit up the locker room and the stadium alike, her confidence contagious. She helped lead the Sooners to multiple Women’s College World Series appearances and etched her name in the NCAA record books with some of the most impressive offensive stats ever recorded. For many fans, Chamberlain’s time at Oklahoma was the epitome of softball excitement.
A true pioneer for the program was Amanda Scarborough, whose all-around skill and leadership helped usher Oklahoma softball into national prominence. Scarborough’s versatility was a hallmark of her career; she excelled both as a hitter and as a defender, and her high softball IQ made her a coach’s dream. Beyond the stats, Scarborough’s influence extended off the field, inspiring younger players and elevating the team culture. Her commitment to excellence set the standard for those who followed, and her contributions are woven into the fabric of Oklahoma’s softball dynasty.
Among pitchers, Keilani Ricketts may get the headlines, but Lauren Bay deserves her own mention for the sheer effectiveness and longevity of her pitching career. Bay’s control and poise on the mound made her a relentless competitor who could shut down even the most dangerous lineups. Her dedication to refining her craft translated into numerous victories and pivotal performances in postseason play. Bay’s resilience in high-pressure moments demonstrated why Oklahoma’s pitching staff has been the envy of college softball for years.
Moving to the outfield, Cheyenne Coyle stands out as a dynamic athlete with a cannon for an arm and a knack for making game-changing defensive plays. Coyle’s speed and instincts allowed her to cover vast territory, turning would-be hits into outs and igniting rallies with her aggressive base running. But she was more than just defense; her clutch hitting in key moments often swung momentum in Oklahoma’s favor. Coyle’s contributions encapsulate the blend of athleticism and baseball savvy that makes Oklahoma softball thrilling to watch.
Another key figure who embodies the spirit of the program is Shelby Pendley, whose time at Oklahoma was marked by an incredible work ethic and steady improvement. Pendley was a consistent offensive threat who also brought versatility in the field. Her dedication to team success over individual glory made her a beloved teammate and an integral part of the Sooners’ lineup. Pendley’s impact may sometimes fly under the radar, but her performances in critical games showcased her ability to rise when it mattered most.
Then there’s Ashley Charters, a player whose determination and grit resonated throughout the program. Charters was known for her fearless approach and ability to deliver under pressure. She was a clutch hitter who often came through with key RBIs in postseason matchups. Her hustle on the bases and aggressive style of play embodied the competitive spirit that Oklahoma softball prides itself on. Charters’ contributions helped solidify the Sooners as a perennial powerhouse during her era.
The list wouldn’t be complete without Nicole Pendley, a player whose impact extended beyond stats. Nicole was a team leader who embodied the values of hard work and dedication. Her defensive prowess and ability to get on base made her a catalyst for the offense. Nicole’s ability to perform in high-stakes moments endeared her to fans and teammates alike, making her an essential piece of Oklahoma’s softball success during her tenure.
Finally, the player who claims the top spot is none other than Keilani Ricketts, a true legend whose legacy defines Oklahoma softball. Her ability to dominate both as a pitcher and hitter, her numerous accolades, and her role in securing national titles place her above all others. Ricketts embodies everything great about Oklahoma softball—skill, heart, leadership, and an unbreakable will to win. Watching her play was witnessing greatness in motion, a performance that still sends chills down the spines of those lucky enough to witness it firsthand.
Each player on this list not only excelled individually but helped elevate the Oklahoma softball program to heights that many programs only dream of. Their combined efforts have created a dynasty defined by national championships, unforgettable moments, and a culture of excellence. Their stories inspire new generations of athletes who step onto the field wearing crimson and cream, eager to add their own chapters to the ongoing legacy.
Debates about who belongs on this list and in what order are inevitable and part of the fun. The beauty of Oklahoma softball is its rich history and the deep well of talent it has produced. From early pioneers who laid the groundwork to modern stars who light up the national stage, these players represent the best of the best. Their achievements resonate not just in record books but in the hearts of fans, the pride of the university, and the ongoing pursuit of greatness.
Whether you’re a diehard fan who has followed every pitch or a newcomer drawn by the excitement of the game, the impact of these players is undeniable. They are the reason Oklahoma softball remains a dominant force in college athletics and why the crimson and cream colors evoke respect and admiration across the softball world.
In the end, this countdown is a celebration—a tribute to the athletes who pushed the boundaries, broke records, and left an indelible mark on the sport. Their legacies are etched in history, and their stories continue to inspire. As Oklahoma softball moves forward, building on this foundation, fans can look back with pride and look ahead with anticipation, knowing that greatness will continue to emerge from this storied program.
So, next time you hear the crack of the bat at the Oklahoma softball stadium or witness a diving catch in the outfield, remember the names that paved the way. Remember the legends who wore the crimson and cream with honor and left the sport forever changed. And remember, the greatest player of all time—the one who gave you chills every time she stepped on the field—is none other than Keilani Ricketts, the heart and soul of Oklahoma softball.
