Report Reveals George Pickens Wasn’t Cowboys’ First Choice — Jerry Jones Initially Targeted Young Ravens Receiver

In a recent twist that has captivated NFL insiders and Dallas Cowboys fans alike, a new report has emerged suggesting that wide receiver George Pickens—now the Cowboys’ latest acquisition—was not the team’s first option. According to multiple sources close to the organization, team owner and general manager Jerry Jones initially set his sights on a different target: a young, ascending wideout from the Baltimore Ravens. Though that deal never materialized, it provides fascinating insight into the Cowboys’ offseason strategy and the unpredictable world of NFL personnel moves.

A Calculated Offseason Strategy

Every NFL offseason is a maze of negotiations, evaluations, and contingency plans. Teams not only scout and draft players, but also prepare for trades and free agency decisions with chess-like precision. The Cowboys, facing increasing pressure to make a deep playoff run, entered the 2025 offseason looking to add firepower to their wide receiver corps—a unit that, while led by All-Pro CeeDee Lamb, lacked depth and consistency behind him.

With quarterback Dak Prescott in his prime and the offensive line solidifying under head coach Mike McCarthy’s system, Dallas knew that an additional top-tier receiver could be the difference-maker. The goal was clear: find a dynamic receiver who could line up opposite Lamb, stretch the field, and provide Prescott with a reliable second option.

Jerry Jones’ First Choice: Rashod Bateman

Sources familiar with the situation revealed that Jerry Jones was initially pursuing Rashod Bateman, the Ravens’ former first-round pick out of Minnesota. Bateman, entering his fourth year in the league, had shown flashes of brilliance in Baltimore, particularly in the 2024 season, where he notched 72 receptions for 912 yards and 6 touchdowns. His combination of route-running precision, speed, and sure hands made him an intriguing fit for Dallas’ offense.

Jones reportedly admired Bateman’s versatility and character, viewing him as a player who could thrive in the Cowboys’ high-volume passing attack. Discussions between Dallas and Baltimore did take place, but ultimately, the Ravens were unwilling to part ways with Bateman unless offered a high draft pick—something Jones and the Cowboys were hesitant to give up.

According to insiders, Baltimore’s asking price included either a future second-round pick or a player-plus-pick combination. Dallas balked at the steep cost, especially considering Bateman’s past injuries and the emergence of rookie Zay Flowers in Baltimore’s system. The Cowboys, committed to improving their team without mortgaging their future, decided to pivot.

Enter George Pickens

With the Bateman deal dead in the water, the Cowboys turned to a player they had quietly been monitoring: George Pickens, the talented and sometimes enigmatic wide receiver from the Pittsburgh Steelers. Pickens had been under a microscope in Pittsburgh—both for his big-play ability and his occasional clashes with team culture—but his talent was undeniable.

In two seasons with the Steelers, Pickens amassed over 2,800 receiving yards and 12 touchdowns. He led the team in explosive plays, contested catches, and yards per reception. But behind the scenes, there were signs that Pittsburgh might be open to a trade, especially as they began restructuring their offense under a new offensive coordinator.

Dallas saw an opportunity and seized it. On May 7, 2025, the Cowboys and Steelers finalized a deal: Dallas would send a 2026 third-round pick and a 2027 fifth-round pick to Pittsburgh in exchange for Pickens, who was entering the final year of his rookie contract.

The trade, while initially surprising to fans, made strategic sense. Pickens brought both youth and experience, as well as a playing style that could complement CeeDee Lamb. And most importantly, Dallas got him without giving up a high-round pick or a starter.

Why the Cowboys Pivoted — And Why It May Work Out

There’s an old adage in football: sometimes, Plan B turns out better than Plan A.

Pickens may not have been Jerry Jones’ first choice, but his upside arguably exceeds that of Bateman. At 6’3″, with long arms and a knack for highlight-reel catches, Pickens adds a physicality to Dallas’ receiving corps that it previously lacked. His ability to win one-on-one matchups, stretch the field vertically, and attack the ball in the air gives Prescott a target that defenses must account for on every play.

There are risks, of course. Pickens has occasionally drawn criticism for inconsistent effort and maturity, and there’s pressure to ensure he integrates well into the Cowboys’ locker room. But Dallas believes that the leadership core—anchored by Lamb, Prescott, and veteran linemen—can provide the structure Pickens needs to thrive.

What This Means for Dak Prescott and the Offense

From a schematic standpoint, adding George Pickens could reshape how the Cowboys approach their offensive game plan. While CeeDee Lamb remains the focal point, defenses will now have to respect Pickens’ deep threat potential, opening up more intermediate and underneath routes.

Offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer has already hinted at expanding the playbook to feature more vertical concepts and play-action shots—something that plays right into Pickens’ strengths. If Pickens can develop chemistry with Prescott during OTAs and training camp, this offense could evolve into one of the most dynamic in the league.

Additionally, Pickens’ presence will benefit other receivers like Jalen Tolbert and tight end Jake Ferguson, who will face fewer double teams as defensive backs shift their attention outward.

Public and Media Reaction

Reactions to the Pickens trade have been mixed—but trending positively.

NFL analysts such as ESPN’s Marcus Spears and NFL Network’s Daniel Jeremiah have praised the Cowboys for taking a calculated risk on a high-upside player without overpaying. “If Pickens buys in,” Spears said during a segment, “Dallas just added a potential Pro Bowler for the price of a Day 2 pick.”

Some fans, however, voiced concerns over the reported failed pursuit of Rashod Bateman. Social media lit up with speculation on whether Jerry Jones’ initial hesitation cost the team a “safer” option. But most seem to agree that Pickens, with his skill set and ceiling, could prove to be a more impactful long-term addition.

What the Ravens Gained — and Lost

From Baltimore’s side, retaining Bateman was both a statement of belief and a practical decision. With Lamar Jackson in MVP form, and new weapons like Zay Flowers and tight end Isaiah Likely ascending, the Ravens decided not to disrupt their offensive continuity.

However, it also signals that Bateman remains central to Baltimore’s long-term plans—at least for now. Had Dallas met their price, Bateman might be wearing a star on his helmet this fall.

Jerry Jones’ Legacy of Bold Moves

This episode adds another chapter to the ongoing saga of Jerry Jones’ tenure as one of the NFL’s most polarizing figures. Known for bold drafts, big trades, and occasionally controversial decisions, Jones continues to put his stamp on the Cowboys’ roster.

While he didn’t land his first target, his ability to pivot and secure a dynamic Plan B shows growth as a strategist and general manager. As the season unfolds, Pickens’ performance will either vindicate or challenge that decision—but one thing is clear: Jones is all-in for 2025.

Final Thoughts

The revelation that George Pickens was not the Cowboys’ first choice adds intrigue to what could be a defining year for Dallas. While Jerry Jones’ pursuit of a Ravens receiver ultimately failed, it led him to a player who may turn out to be the better fit for his team’s needs.

The true measure of this trade will come when the games begin. If Pickens blossoms in Dallas and helps lift the team to postseason success, the question of who was Plan A or B will fade into irrelevance. For now, Cowboys fans can be cautiously optimistic: their team just got better—and possibly much more explosive.