Titans have ‘absolutely not made up their minds’ over quarterback prospects, according to a report.
As the 2025 NFL Draft draws closer, the Tennessee Titans find themselves in a crucial period of evaluation. The Titans, who have long been a competitive team in the AFC, are at a significant crossroads. The key question that looms over the organization as they enter the draft cycle is this: who will be their next franchise quarterback?
The Titans have relied on veteran Ryan Tannehill for much of the last decade, but it’s clear that his best years are behind him. As the Titans look to rebuild or retool, they are faced with the dilemma of whether to take the plunge and draft a quarterback for the future, or whether they should explore other options, including possibly trading up or down in the draft to secure a top player at a different position.
According to recent reports, the Titans have “absolutely not made up their minds” over which quarterback prospect they plan to target in the 2025 draft. This uncertainty could be a blessing or a curse, depending on how the organization approaches this critical decision. With the stakes higher than ever, the Titans’ management must make the right call. Whether they opt for one of the top quarterbacks available or decide to go in another direction could impact the franchise’s future for years to come.
In this article, we will delve deeper into the Titans’ quarterback situation, why they have yet to settle on a prospect, the potential quarterbacks available in the 2025 draft, and how the decision could affect the franchise’s trajectory.
The Titans’ Current Quarterback Situation
Before we dive into the draft prospects, it’s important to first understand the Titans’ current quarterback situation. Ryan Tannehill has been a reliable, albeit inconsistent, starter for Tennessee since joining the team in 2019. His time in Nashville has been marked by flashes of brilliance, including leading the team to the AFC Championship Game in 2019, but also by stretches of poor play, especially in recent seasons.
The most glaring issue for Tannehill is his age. At 36 years old, Tannehill is entering the twilight of his career. Although he is still capable of playing at a high level, it’s clear that the Titans need to start thinking about their quarterback of the future. The longer they delay making this decision, the more difficult it will become to transition to a new era.
In addition to Tannehill’s age, the Titans’ offense has experienced a regression in recent years. The team has relied heavily on running back Derrick Henry, but as the league has shifted toward a more pass-heavy approach, Tennessee has struggled to keep pace. Tannehill’s limitations in the passing game have become more pronounced, and the Titans are in need of a more dynamic and consistent quarterback to compete at a high level in the modern NFL.
While Tannehill’s presence has been stabilizing, it’s clear that the Titans need to develop a successor. The question is whether they believe that successor exists in the 2025 draft class or if they should explore other options to find their quarterback of the future.
The Titans’ Draft Approach: “Absolutely Not Made Up Their Minds”
As the 2025 NFL Draft approaches, the Titans are grappling with a difficult question: who is their quarterback of the future? According to recent reports, the Titans have yet to settle on a specific quarterback prospect. This statement, coming from sources within the organization, indicates that there is no clear consensus on which quarterback the team should target.
This uncertainty could be driven by several factors. First, the 2025 draft class is still in its early stages, and the Titans are likely taking their time to evaluate the prospects thoroughly. Quarterback evaluations can be incredibly subjective, and teams must consider not only physical traits like arm strength, mobility, and accuracy, but also intangibles such as leadership, football IQ, and the ability to thrive in high-pressure situations.
Another factor that may be influencing the Titans’ decision is the variety of quarterbacks available in the 2025 draft. While some may prefer one style of quarterback over another, the Titans have to evaluate how each potential prospect fits into their system and whether they believe a particular player can step in and succeed early on. It’s also possible that Tennessee is weighing the risks and rewards of drafting a quarterback early, especially considering how difficult it is to predict the success of college quarterbacks transitioning to the NFL.
Moreover, the Titans could also be evaluating their options beyond the draft. While the quarterback class is one of the most anticipated in years, there are always veteran options available, whether through free agency or trade. The Titans may be considering whether to spend a high draft pick on a quarterback or if they should pursue a veteran signal-caller who might provide more immediate stability, especially if they believe they are just one or two pieces away from contending.
Quarterback Prospects in the 2025 Draft
The uncertainty surrounding the Titans’ decision likely stems from the talent pool of quarterbacks available in the 2025 draft. The class is considered to be one of the deepest in recent memory, with several top-tier prospects offering a variety of playing styles, skill sets, and leadership qualities. Let’s take a closer look at some of the quarterbacks the Titans could potentially target and how they might fit into the team’s future.
- Caleb Williams (USC)
Caleb Williams is widely regarded as one of the top quarterbacks in the 2025 draft class. The USC standout has been dominant at the college level, showing off his impressive arm strength, accuracy, and mobility. Williams’ ability to make throws from various platforms and his poise in the pocket have made him one of the most highly touted quarterback prospects in years.
For the Titans, Williams presents an intriguing option. His ability to extend plays with his legs and make deep throws could open up the team’s offense in ways they haven’t been able to with Tannehill. Additionally, Williams’ leadership qualities and calm demeanor under pressure could be assets for a team looking to transition to a new quarterback.
However, Williams is expected to go early in the draft, and the Titans may need to trade up to secure him, which could cost them significant assets. Given the uncertainty in the draft, it’s not clear whether they’re willing to make that move.
- Drake Maye (North Carolina)
Another top quarterback prospect in the 2025 class is Drake Maye, who has impressed with his arm strength, accuracy, and mobility. Maye is a prototypical pocket passer with the ability to make all the throws, and his size and poise make him a promising prospect. He’s been a rising star at North Carolina and has the potential to be a day-one starter in the NFL.
For the Titans, Maye would bring stability and a high ceiling as a long-term solution. He doesn’t possess the same level of athleticism as some of the other quarterbacks in the class, but his ability to read defenses, make quick decisions, and lead a team could make him a great fit for the Titans’ offense. Whether Tennessee targets Maye or not will depend on how they evaluate his potential and whether they believe he can immediately elevate the team.
- Quinn Ewers (Texas)
Quinn Ewers is another intriguing option in the 2025 draft class. The Texas quarterback has flashed incredible arm strength and potential but has yet to consistently put everything together. Ewers’ development over the next few months will be crucial for his draft stock, but he remains one of the most highly regarded quarterbacks in the class.
For the Titans, Ewers presents an interesting option as a developmental quarterback. His raw talent is undeniable, but his ability to refine his skills and adjust to the speed of the NFL will be key. If the Titans opt for a quarterback with a higher ceiling but more risk, Ewers could be a potential fit.
- J.J. McCarthy (Michigan)
J.J. McCarthy, the Michigan quarterback, is another potential target for the Titans. McCarthy is an athletic quarterback with the ability to make plays on the move, and his leadership on Michigan’s run to the College Football Playoff has drawn significant attention. His ability to improvise and create plays outside the pocket could make him an attractive prospect for teams looking for a more mobile quarterback.
The Titans’ interest in McCarthy could depend on whether they believe his skill set fits their system. His dual-threat ability could add a new dimension to their offense, but questions remain about his consistency and decision-making. If the Titans are looking for a more dynamic quarterback who can create with his legs, McCarthy might be an option to consider.
The Titans’ Decision-Making Process
With such a deep and talented quarterback class, the Titans are undoubtedly taking their time to carefully evaluate each prospect. The decision they make regarding their future quarterback will impact the franchise for years to come. They must weigh not only the skills and potential of each player but also how well that player fits into the team’s offensive scheme and overall culture.
In addition to evaluating the prospects themselves, the Titans must also consider the trade market. If the Titans are not sold on any of the quarterbacks available at the first overall pick, they may look to trade down and accumulate more assets. With several quarterback-needy teams at the top of the draft order, the Titans could potentially find themselves in a position to leverage their pick for future value.
