Edmonton Oilers Under NHL Investigation as Gary Bettman Probes Evander Kane Situation Following Alarming Allegations and Player Conduct Concerns
The Edmonton Oilers find themselves at the center of an intensifying investigation led by NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman regarding forward Evander Kane, whose turbulent past and recent off-ice behavior have once again placed him — and now the franchise — under serious league scrutiny.
Multiple league sources confirmed that the NHL has opened an official investigation into Kane’s activities and the Oilers’ possible handling or mishandling of relevant matters. Commissioner Bettman is reportedly directly involved in overseeing the review, signaling the gravity of the situation. The Oilers have yet to make a formal public comment, but insiders say the organization is fully cooperating with the league office.
The scope of the investigation is said to encompass potential violations of the NHL’s player conduct policy, including financial disclosures, personal behavior, and adherence to team and league protocols. Though details remain confidential, the inquiry has rocked an Oilers franchise that only recently returned to national prominence after a deep playoff run.
Background: Kane’s History of Controversy
Evander Kane, 32, is no stranger to controversy. A talented but polarizing figure in the NHL, Kane has dealt with multiple off-ice issues throughout his career. From legal battles with creditors, a high-profile bankruptcy filing, to domestic allegations and accusations of gambling on NHL games — many of which were investigated and later dismissed — Kane’s presence has often come with baggage.
When the Oilers signed him in January 2022 after his tumultuous exit from the San Jose Sharks, it was widely seen as a gamble. However, Kane quickly silenced critics by becoming one of Edmonton’s most productive forwards, particularly during the 2022 playoffs. The risk initially seemed worth the reward.
But now, with a fresh round of concerns, that decision is being scrutinized under a much harsher light.
Why the NHL is Investigating Now
Sources indicate that the NHL’s latest inquiry stems from a combination of recent reports and new evidence submitted regarding Kane’s conduct — including personal disputes and his business dealings during the offseason.
While the league has not publicly disclosed the specifics, several NHL executives speaking anonymously pointed to what they described as “irregularities” in Kane’s interactions with financial institutions, as well as potential violations of the NHL’s code of conduct that could implicate the Oilers if organizational oversight is questioned.
There’s also concern surrounding how much the Oilers front office knew, and when they knew it. That timeline is a central focus of Bettman’s inquiry. If the investigation finds that the Oilers failed to disclose or report significant concerns about Kane’s behavior, the franchise could face disciplinary action from the league, ranging from fines to possible sanctions.
Gary Bettman’s Involvement Raises Stakes
Commissioner Gary Bettman’s direct involvement has added a sense of urgency and seriousness to the proceedings. Bettman, who has often taken a hands-on approach with high-profile league matters, reportedly called for a full review after receiving reports from multiple parties — including player representatives and outside legal consultants.
A senior league official described Bettman’s involvement as “precautionary, but determined,” emphasizing that while Kane is presumed innocent until proven otherwise, the league has a responsibility to uphold its standards.
“This isn’t just about one player anymore,” the official said. “This is about setting an example for how the NHL handles its most sensitive matters, both ethically and organizationally.”
Oilers’ Role Under the Microscope
As the investigation deepens, questions swirl around the Oilers’ internal protocols. Did the team adequately vet Kane’s background? Have they consistently monitored and documented his behavior since joining the team? Did they alert the league to any red flags?
Edmonton GM Ken Holland, who has publicly supported Kane in the past, is reportedly cooperating with NHL officials. But sources inside the organization say there is mounting concern that even if the player is ultimately cleared, the optics of this situation could tarnish the club’s reputation.
“There was always risk in bringing Evander here,” one Oilers staffer admitted under anonymity. “But he gave us an edge on the ice. That’s hard to walk away from — even when you know the off-ice part might blow up.”
Teammates React Quietly
Several Oilers players, including captain Connor McDavid, have reportedly been briefed on the investigation. However, no one has made public statements. Internally, sources say the locker room is trying to remain focused on offseason preparation, with training camp just weeks away.
“It’s a distraction, no doubt,” one veteran said. “But it’s something management and the league are dealing with. As players, we try to stay out of it unless asked to help.”
That said, some within the NHL Players’ Association are concerned that Kane may be treated unfairly due to his past, even if the latest concerns remain unverified. The NHLPA is said to be monitoring the situation closely and is prepared to defend Kane’s rights if necessary.
What’s Next?
The NHL’s investigation is expected to unfold over several weeks, and sources say no immediate suspension or disciplinary action is forthcoming — at least not yet. However, should the findings reveal major misconduct or evidence of organizational failure, the league could act swiftly and decisively.
For the Oilers, the timing is far from ideal. After advancing to the Stanley Cup Final and falling short against the Florida Panthers, the team is seen as a top contender entering the 2025 season. Any off-ice distraction, particularly one involving a high-profile player like Kane, could threaten that momentum.
The Bigger Picture for the NHL
This investigation also raises broader questions about how the NHL handles troubled players and the pressure teams face to win at all costs. Kane’s situation isn’t unique in professional sports — but it is perhaps one of the most visible in hockey right now.
“There’s a delicate balance between second chances and accountability,” said one former NHL executive. “Kane has been given more than one opportunity. The league and the Oilers are now being judged on how seriously they take the consequences.”
If the NHL concludes that Edmonton turned a blind eye to mounting issues, the repercussions could be precedent-setting. And for Gary Bettman, who is nearing the 32-year mark of his tenure as commissioner, this may serve as one of his most closely watched disciplinary reviews in years.
Kane’s Response
As of now, Evander Kane has not publicly commented on the investigation. His representatives declined requests for interviews but issued a brief statement saying that he “remains focused on his offseason training and is fully prepared to cooperate with the NHL on any matter.”
Kane, who posted 27 goals and 23 assists in the 2024-25 season, is entering a pivotal year in his contract and remains an integral part of the Oilers’ offensive core.
Whether he will remain a centerpiece of their plans moving forward may now depend on what unfolds in the coming weeks.
The Edmonton Oilers’ gamble on Evander Kane is once again under the spotlight — not for his scoring, but for off-ice issues that threaten to cast a shadow over the entire organization. With NHL Commissioner Gary Bettman personally overseeing an investigation into Kane’s conduct and the Oilers’ role in managing it, the stakes have never been higher. The outcome could define Kane’s future, alter Edmonton’s plans, and reshape how the NHL handles controversial stars going forward.
