The Oilers call double standard, with one brutal error
In the aftermath of the Edmonton Oilers’ 6–1 loss to the Florida Panthers in Game 3 of the 2025 Stanley Cup Finals, the team finds itself embroiled in controversy, not only due to their on-ice performance but also because of what many perceive as a double standard in officiating. The game was marked by a staggering 35 penalties—21 against Edmonton and 14 against Florida—including eight misconducts and one ejection . This lopsided penalty distribution has led to widespread criticism and frustration among Oilers players, coaching staff, and fans alike.
One of the most glaring issues highlighted was the inconsistency in penalty enforcement. Oilers forward Evander Kane expressed his dissatisfaction with the officiating, suggesting that the Panthers were allowed to push the boundaries of physicality without facing the same consequences as Edmonton players . This sentiment was echoed by fans and analysts, who pointed out that similar actions by Florida players often went unpunished, while the Oilers were penalized more frequently for comparable infractions.
The disparity in penalty calls has raised questions about the NHL’s approach to officiating, particularly in high-stakes playoff games. Critics argue that such inconsistencies not only affect the outcome of individual games but also undermine the integrity of the sport.
In response to the events of Game 3, the NHL took disciplinary action against Oilers defenseman Jake Walman, issuing him a double fine for his behavior during the third period . While this move was intended to address misconduct on the ice, it has further fueled the perception of a double standard. Many feel that if the league is quick to penalize Oilers players, similar actions by Panthers players should also result in comparable consequences.
The NHL’s disciplinary decisions have been a point of contention throughout the playoffs. In previous games, fans and media have criticized the league for missed calls and inconsistent enforcement of rules, particularly concerning star players like Connor McDavid . The latest incident has only intensified these concerns, leading to calls for a more balanced and transparent approach to officiating.
The perceived double standard in officiating has had a significant impact on the Oilers, both on and off the ice. Head coach Kris Knoblauch and captain Leon Draisaitl have addressed the team’s ongoing discipline issues, emphasizing the need for improved performance and control to turn the series around . However, the constant scrutiny and the challenges posed by the officiating have added an additional layer of pressure on the team.
The Oilers now face a critical test of discipline and resilience as they prepare for Game 4. If they are to overcome the Panthers and level the series, they must not only focus on their performance but also navigate the complexities of officiating that have become a central narrative of these Finals.
The events of Game 3 have highlighted significant concerns regarding officiating in the Stanley Cup Finals. The perceived double standard in penalty calls and disciplinary actions has sparked widespread debate and frustration. As the series progresses, it remains to be seen how these issues will influence the outcome and whether the NHL will take steps to address the concerns raised by players, coaches, and fans.
