Deciding who should advance in our Ohio State football ‘The Greatest Buckeye’ bracket between Archie Griffin and A.J. Hawk is a challenging and thought-provoking task that requires a deep dive into their careers, impact, and legacies within Ohio State football history. Both players epitomize excellence at different eras, roles, and styles, making this matchup a true test of greatness. To thoroughly evaluate who deserves to move forward, we will explore their backgrounds, statistical achievements, leadership qualities, influence on Ohio State’s success, and broader contributions to college football. Ultimately, this analysis aims to provide a comprehensive perspective, honoring both legends while determining which Buckeye truly stands above in this historic rivalry of Ohio State’s greatest.

Ohio State football, with its storied history dating back over a century, has produced numerous legendary players, coaches, and moments that have shaped college football. The ‘Greatest Buckeye’ bracket is a celebration of those iconic figures, aiming to crown the ultimate Ohio State football legend through a competitive, bracket-style format. Each matchup demands a careful consideration of individual achievements, leadership, influence, and enduring legacy. Archie Griffin and A.J. Hawk, representing different generations and roles, exemplify the diversity of greatness Ohio State has fostered.

—

### 2. Archie Griffin: The Dual Heisman Winner and Running Back Legend

#### Background and Career Highlights

Archie Griffin, hailing from Columbus, Ohio—just like his college alma mater—embodies the quintessential Buckeye. Enrolling at Ohio State in 1972, Griffin’s college career spanned four seasons from 1972 to 1975. He is best known for being the only player in NCAA history to win the Heisman Trophy twice (1974 and 1975), a feat that underscores his exceptional talent and consistency. Griffin was a workhorse, a symbol of durability, leadership, and excellence.

#### Statistical Achievements

– **Rushing yards:** 5,589 yards on 951 carries (5.9 yards per carry)
– **Touchdowns:** 26 rushing touchdowns
– **All-American honors:** 1974, 1975
– **Leadership:** Team captain as a senior
– **Awards:** Two-time Heisman Trophy winner, First-team All-American, Big Ten Player of the Year (1974)

His rushing yards stood as the NCAA record for career rushing yards until 1989, and his consistent production made him a dominant force on the field.

#### Leadership and Impact

Archie Griffin was not just a prolific rusher; he was a leader and a symbol of Ohio State’s resilience and tradition. He exemplified humility, work ethic, and team-first mentality, inspiring teammates and fans alike. His durability—playing through injuries and carrying the load for Ohio State—made him a beloved figure, and his character off the field matched his excellence on it.

#### Influence on Ohio State’s Success

During Griffin’s tenure, Ohio State was a national powerhouse, winning three Big Ten titles and earning multiple bowl appearances. His contributions helped solidify Ohio State’s reputation as a premier program and set a standard for future generations.

#### Legacy and Cultural Significance

Archie Griffin’s legacy extends beyond his statistical achievements; he is a cultural icon in Ohio and college football. His commitment to community, sportsmanship, and excellence has made him a role model for countless athletes.

—

### 3. A.J. Hawk: The Dominant Linebacker and Leadership Pillar

#### Background and Career Highlights

A.J. Hawk, hailing from Centerville, Ohio, played for Ohio State from 2002 to 2005. As a linebacker, Hawk was known for his relentless motor, football IQ, and leadership. His career coincided with Ohio State’s rise to national prominence under coach Jim Tressel, and Hawk was a central figure in that success.

#### Statistical Achievements

– **Tackles:** 355 career tackles
– **Sacks:** 13.5 sacks
– **Interceptions:** 5 interceptions
– **Awards:** Big Ten Defensive Player of the Year (2005), First-team All-American, Lombardi Award finalist
– **Leadership:** Team captain in 2005, leader of Ohio State’s legendary defense

Hawk’s on-field production and leadership earned him recognition as one of the top linebackers in college football history.

#### Leadership and Impact

Hawk’s intangibles—his work ethic, intelligence, and ability to motivate teammates—made him a natural leader. He was the glue that held Ohio State’s defense together, orchestrating adjustments and inspiring players to elevate their game. His vocal presence and example of dedication helped Ohio State compile dominant defensive performances.

#### Influence on Ohio State’s Success

Hawk’s leadership was instrumental in Ohio State’s 2002 BCS National Championship season and subsequent Big Ten titles. His ability to read offenses, make plays, and rally his team made him a cornerstone of Ohio State’s defense during a golden era.

#### Legacy and Broader Influence

After college, Hawk’s NFL career with the Green Bay Packers further cemented his reputation as a premier linebacker. His Ohio State legacy is rooted in his leadership, football intelligence, and impact on the program’s resurgence as a national powerhouse.

—

### 4. Comparing the Two Legends: Key Aspects

#### Individual Achievements

– **Archie Griffin:** Unique two-time Heisman winner; NCAA career rushing record; embodies excellence at the running back position.
– **A.J. Hawk:** Dominant linebacker with multiple individual awards; leader of a top-tier defense; high NFL draft pick.

#### Leadership and Intangibles

– Griffin’s leadership was exemplified through his work ethic, humility, and being a symbolic figure of Buckeye tradition.
– Hawk’s leadership was more vocal and tactical, guiding defenses and motivating teammates on the field.

#### Impact on Ohio State’s Success

– Griffin helped establish Ohio State as a national power in the 1970s, setting standards for future running backs.
– Hawk contributed to Ohio State’s national championships and sustained success in the early 2000s, helping Ohio State become a modern football powerhouse.

#### Cultural and Broader Legacy

– Griffin’s legacy is deeply rooted in Ohio culture, embodying perseverance, humility, and excellence.
– Hawk’s legacy is tied to leadership, defensive prowess, and inspiring teams to perform at their best.

—

### 5. The Case for ‘The Greatest Buckeye’

Choosing between Griffin and Hawk hinges on criteria: individual greatness, leadership, team success, cultural impact, and lasting legacy.

– **Archie Griffin’s case:** His unparalleled achievement of winning two Heismans, setting NCAA records, and symbolizing Buckeye tradition makes him arguably the most iconic player in Ohio State history. His impact transcends statistics, representing perseverance, humility, and excellence. His influence helped elevate Ohio State’s national profile in the 1970s.

– **A.J. Hawk’s case:** His dominance as a linebacker, leadership during Ohio State’s resurgence, and NFL success showcase a different kind of greatness—one that emphasizes leadership, versatility, and sustained excellence at a high level of competition.

**Ultimately,** many would argue that Griffin’s unique achievement of consecutive Heisman wins and his embodiment of Ohio State’s ideals place him slightly ahead in the ‘Greatest Buckeye’ debate. His cultural significance and pioneering role in Buckeye history make him a compelling choice. However, Hawk’s leadership, defensive mastery, and NFL career solidify his own claim as a Buckeye legend.

In this head-to-head matchup, **Archie Griffin** edges out as the ‘Greatest Buckeye’ due to his unparalleled individual accomplishments, national recognition, and symbolic status in Ohio State history. His two Heisman Trophies, NCAA records, and embodiment of Buckeye values set a gold standard for excellence. His impact helped shape the identity of Ohio State football and inspired generations.

Nevertheless, **A.J. Hawk** remains a titan of Ohio State’s modern era, representing leadership, defensive excellence, and the championship spirit. His legacy is equally profound, especially among fans who value defensive mastery and leadership.

**In conclusion,** both players are essential threads in Ohio State’s rich tapestry. Choosing Griffin as the ultimate ‘Greatest Buckeye’ recognizes his historic achievements and cultural impact, but acknowledging Hawk’s greatness affirms Ohio State’s tradition of producing versatile, impactful leaders. This debate underscores the diversity of greatness in Buckeye history, and whichever side one favors, both players epitomize the excellence and enduring legacy of Ohio State football.