Former LSU WR Brian Thomas Jr. Compares Garrett Nussmeier to Jayden Daniels, Highlights Key Differences and Potential.

In the high-stakes world of college football, quarterback play is often the single most defining element of a program’s success. At LSU, the bar has been set astronomically high in recent years thanks to the transcendent performances of quarterbacks like Joe Burrow and Jayden Daniels. As the Tigers look ahead to the 2025 season, much of that spotlight now shines on Garrett Nussmeier — a player many believe has the tools to follow in their legendary footsteps.

And no one may be more qualified to weigh in on that potential than former LSU wide receiver Brian Thomas Jr., who caught passes from both Daniels and Nussmeier during his decorated college career. In a recent interview, Thomas offered candid insight into both quarterbacks, drawing comparisons and pointing out critical differences in their approach, playing style, and leadership qualities.

In doing so, Thomas not only opened a window into the dynamics inside LSU’s quarterback room but also helped frame the growing narrative around Nussmeier’s future as the Tigers’ next big star under center.

A Trusted Voice Weighs In

Brian Thomas Jr., a projected top pick in the 2025 NFL Draft and one of LSU’s most productive wide receivers over the last three seasons, played alongside both quarterbacks and saw firsthand how each operated in the huddle, on the field, and behind the scenes.

Speaking with local and national media following LSU’s Pro Day and NFL Combine appearances, Thomas was asked about Garrett Nussmeier and how he compares to Jayden Daniels — LSU’s Heisman Trophy-winning quarterback and current NFL rookie with the Washington Commanders.

His response was thoughtful, deliberate, and full of praise.

“Jayden was a calm, surgical quarterback — he picked you apart with precision. Garrett’s a little more aggressive, more of a gunslinger,” Thomas said. “He’s got that confidence. He wants to make the big throw every time. But don’t mistake that for recklessness — he’s been patient and he’s learned from the best.”

Thomas went on to highlight how Nussmeier’s development over the past two seasons — particularly under the mentorship of Daniels — has positioned him well for a breakout year in 2025.

Jayden Daniels: The Benchmark

To fully appreciate the comparison, it’s important to understand just how high the bar has been set.

Jayden Daniels’ 2023 season at LSU was one of the most electrifying in program history. He passed for over 3,800 yards and 40 touchdowns while rushing for more than 1,100 yards, making him just the second quarterback in FBS history to accomplish such a feat in a single season. His dual-threat ability and field vision made him nearly unstoppable, and his leadership transformed LSU into a legitimate College Football Playoff contender.

Daniels’ Heisman Trophy win solidified his legacy at LSU, placing him in the same rarified air as Joe Burrow, who won the award in 2019. But his influence went beyond stats and accolades. He helped mold the culture of LSU’s offense — an approach centered on preparation, discipline, and maximizing the talent around him.

That culture is now being passed to Nussmeier.

Garrett Nussmeier: The Next Chapter

Garrett Nussmeier has patiently waited his turn, spending the last two seasons as Daniels’ backup while also making the most of limited opportunities. Known for his arm talent and football IQ, Nussmeier came to LSU as a highly touted four-star recruit with NFL pedigree — his father, Doug Nussmeier, played quarterback in the NFL and has served as an offensive coordinator at both the collegiate and professional levels.

Though Nussmeier could have entered the transfer portal — as many backup quarterbacks do in search of immediate playing time — he chose to stay and develop in Baton Rouge. That decision is now paying off, and the 2025 season offers the chance for him to make his mark in a program known for producing elite quarterback play.

Brian Thomas Jr. believes that patience and work ethic will soon be rewarded.

“Garrett could’ve left. He could’ve gone anywhere. But he stayed, learned, and now he’s ready. He’s got the tools. He’s got the fire. And now he’s got the stage,” Thomas said.

Comparing the Styles

When asked to compare Daniels and Nussmeier from a receiver’s perspective, Thomas painted a clear picture of their stylistic differences.

• Jayden Daniels: A cerebral quarterback who made quick decisions and rarely put the ball in harm’s way. His ability to extend plays with his legs and throw on the run opened up the field in unique ways.
• Garrett Nussmeier: More of a traditional pocket passer with elite arm strength and a willingness to push the ball downfield. Thomas emphasized Nussmeier’s timing and trust in his receivers to make contested catches.

“With Jayden, you knew the ball was coming if you were open. With Garrett, he’ll give you a chance to make a play even when you’re covered,” Thomas explained. “It makes you feel like every route could be a game-changer.”

This gunslinger mentality is reminiscent of Joe Burrow, who consistently gave his receivers — Ja’Marr Chase, Justin Jefferson, Terrace Marshall — chances to win one-on-one matchups. If Nussmeier can find similar chemistry with LSU’s 2025 receiving corps, the offense could remain among the SEC’s best.

Leadership and Intangibles

While physical tools are critical, leadership and poise under pressure often separate good quarterbacks from great ones. According to Thomas, both Daniels and Nussmeier are exceptional in their own ways.

“Jayden led with calm. He was always even-keeled. Garrett brings that fire. You hear him in the huddle, he gets guys hyped. Both styles work — it’s about being authentic. And Garrett is 100% himself.”

Coaches and teammates have echoed similar sentiments. LSU head coach Brian Kelly has praised Nussmeier’s maturity, saying during spring practices, “Garrett has grown tremendously in his understanding of what it takes to be the face of this program. He’s confident, he’s prepared, and he’s leading the right way.”

The Supporting Cast

As Nussmeier prepares to take over the offense full-time, the pieces around him will play a key role in determining just how successful he can be. Fortunately, LSU has reloaded on offense.

Key returning players include:

• Malik Nabers – The dynamic All-American wideout and likely first-round NFL Draft pick returns for one more season to anchor the receiver room.
• Kyren Lacy – A reliable target who came on strong late in the season and offers a big frame for red-zone situations.
• Mason Taylor – One of the top tight ends in the country, Taylor provides Nussmeier with a safety blanket in the middle of the field.
• Elite RBs – LSU’s stable of running backs includes explosive talents who can catch passes out of the backfield, keeping defenses honest.

Offensive coordinator Mike Denbrock also returns, ensuring continuity in play-calling and scheme. That familiarity should ease Nussmeier’s transition and help maintain offensive rhythm.

A Heisman-Worthy Season?

The natural question among fans and analysts is whether Nussmeier can replicate the kind of magical senior season enjoyed by Daniels and Burrow before him.

Brian Thomas Jr. didn’t hesitate when asked.

“If he gets hot, he can win the Heisman,” Thomas said. “He’s got the arm, he’s got the weapons, and now he’s got the keys. He just needs to drive.”

It’s a bold prediction, but not an unreasonable one. LSU’s recent history suggests that when their quarterback is in sync with his skill players, explosive results follow. Nussmeier will be given every opportunity to light up scoreboards, and if he stays healthy, he could quickly become one of college football’s most talked-about players.

A Season of High Expectations

The 2025 campaign will open with LSU ranked among the preseason top 10 in most polls. With a manageable early schedule, Nussmeier will have time to find his rhythm before the SEC gauntlet begins.

Games against Alabama, Georgia, and Texas loom large, but also offer prime opportunities for Nussmeier to show what he’s capable of on the national stage. Much like Daniels elevated his draft stock with standout performances in marquee matchups, Nussmeier could do the same — and boost LSU’s playoff hopes in the process.

The baton has been passed.

With Jayden Daniels now preparing for Sundays in the NFL, Garrett Nussmeier steps into a role filled with immense expectations and even greater opportunity. If you ask Brian Thomas Jr. — someone who knows both quarterbacks better than most — the Tigers are in good hands.

Nussmeier may not be the same style of quarterback as Daniels, but that’s not a bad thing. His confidence, arm talent, and willingness to take risks make him a different kind of weapon — one that could carve out a legacy all his own.

“He’s ready,” Thomas said with a smile. “LSU’s in good shape.”

Time will tell just how far Nussmeier can take the Tigers. But if his talent meets his opportunity, LSU fans might soon be adding another name to their list of quarterback legends.