Is K Tyler Loop a potential replacement for Justin Tucker in the Ravens?
The Baltimore Ravens have long been known for their strong special teams, and at the heart of that unit stands Justin Tucker, one of the most accurate and reliable kickers in NFL history. However, with Tucker now 35 years old and facing off-field controversies, the Ravens have begun to look toward the future. In the 2025 NFL Draft, they selected kicker Tyler Loop from the University of Arizona in the sixth round (186th overall), potentially signaling the beginning of a transition at the kicker position. (Arizona Desert Swarm)
Tyler Loop had a standout career at Arizona, becoming the school’s all-time leader in field goal percentage with an impressive 86.4% (49-of-57) conversion rate. He also set a program record with a 62-yard field goal in 2024 and was named a semifinalist for the Lou Groza Award, which honors the nation’s top kicker. Loop’s consistency and leg strength were evident throughout his college tenure, making him one of the most promising kicking prospects in recent years.(GoPHNX, University of Arizona Athletics)
Justin Tucker has been the Ravens’ kicker since 2012, earning seven Pro Bowl selections and five First-Team All-Pro honors. He holds the NFL record for the longest field goal made in a game (66 yards) and is known for his clutch performances. However, Tucker’s performance in 2024 showed signs of decline, as he converted only 73.3% of his field goal attempts, the lowest of his career. Additionally, Tucker is currently under NFL investigation following allegations from 16 women accusing him of inappropriate behavior at Baltimore-area spas between 2012 and 2016. Although Tucker has denied the claims, the situation has cast uncertainty over his future with the team. (Reuters)
The Ravens’ decision to draft Tyler Loop in the sixth round is noteworthy, as they had never previously selected a kicker in the NFL Draft. This move suggests that the team is preparing for a potential transition at the kicker position. Loop’s selection also comes amid the ongoing controversy surrounding Tucker, indicating that the Ravens may be looking to the future while navigating the current situation. (Reuters)
| Category | Justin Tucker | Tyler Loop |
|---|---|---|
| NFL Experience | 13 seasons | Rookie |
| Career Field Goal % | 90.6% | 86.4% |
| Longest Field Goal | 66 yards | 62 yards |
| Lou Groza Semifinalist | Yes (multiple times) | Yes (2023, 2024) |
| Career Highs | Multiple game-winners | Game-winning 24-yard FG |
While Tucker has the edge in experience and career achievements, Loop’s college performance and accolades suggest he has the potential to step into a starting role.
If the Ravens decide to move forward with Tyler Loop as their primary kicker, the transition would likely involve a period of mentorship under Justin Tucker. Given Tucker’s experience and professionalism, he could provide valuable guidance to Loop, helping him adjust to the demands of the NFL. Additionally, Loop would have the opportunity to learn from one of the best in the business, which could accelerate his development.
While it’s uncertain whether Tyler Loop will immediately replace Justin Tucker as the Ravens’ kicker, the team’s decision to draft him indicates a potential shift at the position. Loop’s impressive college career and accolades make him a promising prospect, and with the right development and mentorship, he could become a key contributor to the Ravens’ special teams unit in the near future.
