From Fasano to Mayer: Tracing the Legacy of Notre Dame Tight Ends Drafted Since 2006

Notre Dame has long been recognized as a premier institution for developing tight ends who transition successfully to the NFL. Since 2006, the Fighting Irish have produced a series of standout tight ends, each contributing uniquely to both their collegiate teams and their professional careers. This article delves into the journeys of these athletes, highlighting their college achievements, draft experiences, and subsequent professional endeavors.

1. Anthony Fasano (2006 NFL Draft – 2nd Round, 53rd Overall, Dallas Cowboys)

Anthony Fasano was the first Notre Dame tight end drafted in the 21st century. Throughout his college career, Fasano was known for his reliable hands and strong blocking skills. He played a pivotal role in Notre Dame’s offense, contributing significantly to their success during his tenure.

After being selected by the Dallas Cowboys in the second round of the 2006 NFL Draft, Fasano went on to have a productive 12-year career in the NFL. He played for several teams, including the Cowboys, Miami Dolphins, Kansas City Chiefs, and Tennessee Titans. Fasano was known for his consistency and leadership on and off the field.

2. John Carlson (2008 NFL Draft – 2nd Round, 38th Overall, Seattle Seahawks)

John Carlson was a standout tight end at Notre Dame, earning All-American honors during his college career. He was recognized for his exceptional route running and ability to make plays in the passing game.

Selected by the Seattle Seahawks in the second round of the 2008 NFL Draft, Carlson made an immediate impact in the NFL. He played for several teams, including the Seahawks, Minnesota Vikings, and Arizona Cardinals. Carlson was known for his versatility and ability to contribute both as a receiver and a blocker.

3. Kyle Rudolph (2011 NFL Draft – 2nd Round, 43rd Overall, Minnesota Vikings)

Kyle Rudolph emerged as one of the premier tight ends in college football during his time at Notre Dame. He was known for his exceptional hands and ability to make plays in the red zone. Rudolph’s performance at Notre Dame earned him a spot in the 2011 NFL Draft.

Drafted by the Minnesota Vikings in the second round, Rudolph quickly became a key figure in the NFL. He earned two Pro Bowl selections and established himself as a reliable target in the passing game. Rudolph’s contributions were instrumental in the Vikings’ offensive success during his tenure with the team.

4. Tyler Eifert (2013 NFL Draft – 1st Round, 21st Overall, Cincinnati Bengals)

Tyler Eifert was a standout tight end at Notre Dame, earning first-team All-American honors and winning the John Mackey Award as the nation’s top tight end in 2012. His ability to make plays down the field and in the red zone made him a highly sought-after prospect.

Selected by the Cincinnati Bengals in the first round of the 2013 NFL Draft, Eifert made an immediate impact in the NFL. He earned a Pro Bowl selection in 2015 and became a key contributor to the Bengals’ offense. Eifert’s ability to create mismatches with defenders made him a valuable asset to his team.

5. Troy Niklas (2014 NFL Draft – 2nd Round, 52nd Overall, Arizona Cardinals)

Troy Niklas was known for his exceptional blocking skills and ability to contribute in the running game during his time at Notre Dame. While his receiving numbers were modest, his versatility and physicality made him a valuable asset to the Fighting Irish.

Drafted by the Arizona Cardinals in the second round of the 2014 NFL Draft, Niklas faced challenges in transitioning to the NFL. Injuries and competition for playing time limited his impact at the professional level. Despite these challenges, Niklas’ work ethic and commitment to the game were commendable.

6. Ben Koyack (2015 NFL Draft – 7th Round, 229th Overall, Jacksonville Jaguars)

Ben Koyack was a reliable tight end for Notre Dame, known for his consistency and ability to make crucial catches. His performances in key games showcased his potential as a professional prospect.

Selected by the Jacksonville Jaguars in the seventh round of the 2015 NFL Draft, Koyack’s professional career was marked by perseverance. He spent time on the Jaguars’ practice squad and later had stints with other NFL teams. Koyack’s journey reflects the challenges and realities of professional football.

7. Cole Kmet (2020 NFL Draft – 2nd Round, 43rd Overall, Chicago Bears)

Cole Kmet was a standout tight end at Notre Dame, known for his athleticism and ability to make plays in the passing game. He was a key contributor to the Fighting Irish’s offense during his college career.

Drafted by the Chicago Bears in the second round of the 2020 NFL Draft, Kmet quickly became a central figure in the Bears’ offense. He showcased his skills as both a receiver and a blocker, earning recognition for his contributions. Kmet’s development in the NFL has been closely watched by fans and analysts alike.

8. Michael Mayer (2023 NFL Draft – 2nd Round, 35th Overall, Las Vegas Raiders)

Michael Mayer concluded his college career at Notre Dame as the all-time leader in receptions for a tight end, with 180 catches. His combination of size, hands, and route-running ability made him a top prospect in the 2023 NFL Draft.

Selected by the Las Vegas Raiders in the second round, Mayer began his professional career with high expectations. In his rookie season, he made notable contributions, including scoring his first NFL touchdown.