Alabama Football Quarterback Battle: Five Key Questions After A-Day

As the Alabama Crimson Tide concluded their A-Day spring game, the quarterback competition remains one of the most intriguing storylines heading into the 2025 season. With Jalen Milroe declaring for the NFL Draft , the team is looking to fill the starting role.
1. Who Is Leading the Quarterback Competition?
Ty Simpson, a redshirt junior, has the most experience among the contenders. Having served as Milroe’s primary backup, Simpson has completed 29 of 50 passes for 381 yards over the past three seasons . Austin Mack, a redshirt sophomore and transfer from Washington, has limited game experience but is considered a strong candidate. Freshman Keelon Russell, a five-star recruit, brings high expectations but lacks collegiate experience .
2. What Is Head Coach Kalen DeBoer Looking For?
Coach DeBoer emphasizes the importance of a quarterback who can deliver the ball effectively, command the huddle, and lead the team. He values strong leadership and the ability to execute the offense efficiently .
3. How Will the Offensive Scheme Adapt?
With Milroe’s departure, the offensive scheme may shift to better suit the strengths of the new quarterback. DeBoer may implement a more balanced attack, focusing on the quarterback’s ability to make quick decisions and accurate throws .
4. What Are the Strengths and Weaknesses of Each Candidate?
- Ty Simpson: Strengths include his understanding of the system and leadership experience. However, his limited game experience may be a concern.
- Austin Mack: Brings a strong arm and athleticism but lacks significant playing time.
- Keelon Russell: Offers high potential and talent but is untested at the collegiate level.
5. What Are the Next Steps in the Quarterback Evaluation Process?
The coaching staff will continue to assess each quarterback’s performance in practices leading up to the season opener. Scrimmages and internal evaluations will play a crucial role in determining the starter. DeBoer has expressed confidence in the team’s ability to develop a strong leader from the current roster .