Greg McElroy expressed confidence in Tennessee’s future, stating the Vols are in “win-now mode” despite Nico Iamaleava’s departure. He believes the program’s foundation under Coach Heupel remains strong.

When Nico Iamaleava, the highly anticipated five-star quarterback, made the decision to leave the Tennessee Volunteers, it sent shockwaves through the college football world. His departure came with a swirl of speculation, especially as it was tied to Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) issues and a broader conversation about the evolving landscape of college sports. Many pundits and fans alike were left wondering how Tennessee would bounce back after losing a player considered to be the future of the program.
However, not everyone is singing the same tune. Greg McElroy, the former Alabama quarterback and current college football analyst, remains positive about the Vols’ trajectory. Despite the blow of Iamaleava’s departure, McElroy has a positive outlook on Tennessee’s future and believes the team is still in “win-now mode.” According to McElroy, the Volunteers are poised for success despite losing one of their most promising recruits in recent years.
In this piece, we’ll explore McElroy’s remarks, break down Tennessee’s current position, and assess how the program might continue to thrive under head coach Josh Heupel, even without Iamaleava at the helm.
Nico Iamaleava’s Departure: The Shockwave Felt Across College Football
Nico Iamaleava’s recruitment was one of the most closely watched in recent memory. The quarterback’s combination of size, athleticism, and arm strength made him one of the most coveted prospects of his class. Committing to Tennessee in 2023, Iamaleava was seen as a cornerstone of the Volunteers’ future, someone who could potentially lead the team to SEC prominence and beyond.
However, just as quickly as Iamaleava’s star rose, his departure from the program left a hole in Tennessee’s quarterback room. The news was both surprising and disappointing for Tennessee fans, as Iamaleava’s arrival had generated significant excitement around the Vols’ potential resurgence in the SEC. His exit has raised questions about Tennessee’s recruiting strategy, its handling of NIL opportunities, and what lies ahead for the program.
Reports suggest that Iamaleava’s decision to leave Tennessee stemmed from dissatisfaction with how his NIL opportunities were managed by the program. As NIL has become an increasingly influential force in college football, many high-profile recruits are factoring in the financial aspect of their college decision. In Iamaleava’s case, a mismatch between expectations and reality led to a breakup between the quarterback and the program. As a result, the Vols were left to adjust their strategy moving forward.
Greg McElroy’s Optimism for Tennessee: “Win-Now Mode”
Despite the shockwaves caused by Iamaleava’s departure, Greg McElroy has a much more positive outlook on the state of Tennessee football. McElroy, who starred at Alabama and won a national championship in 2009, has become one of the most respected analysts in college football. His expertise and insight are valued by fans, players, and coaches alike.
When asked about the Volunteers’ future, McElroy expressed confidence in the program’s trajectory. He believes that Tennessee is still in “win-now mode,” a statement that reflects his belief in the team’s potential despite the absence of a five-star quarterback. According to McElroy, the foundation that Josh Heupel has built in Knoxville is solid enough to weather the loss of one player, no matter how high-profile that player may be.
“I think Tennessee is in win-now mode,” McElroy said during a recent broadcast. “They’ve got a lot of talent on the roster, they’ve got a dynamic offense, and Josh Heupel has proven he can develop quarterbacks. Just because you lose one guy doesn’t mean the entire program is falling apart. This is still a team with a lot of potential to compete at a high level in the SEC.”
Why McElroy Is Confident in Tennessee’s Future
To understand McElroy’s optimism, it’s important to examine the factors that make Tennessee a strong team even without Iamaleava. While losing a five-star quarterback is never easy, Tennessee still has a great deal of talent and an offense that has proven effective under Heupel. Let’s break down some of the reasons why McElroy believes the Vols are in “win-now mode.”
1. Josh Heupel’s Offensive System
One of the biggest factors in Tennessee’s success has been the high-octane offense implemented by head coach Josh Heupel. Heupel, who took over the program in 2021, is known for his fast-paced, pass-heavy attack that takes advantage of spread formations, up-tempo playcalling, and a dynamic quarterback. His system allows for explosive plays, which is a perfect fit for a program like Tennessee, which has talent at the skill positions.
While Iamaleava was expected to be a perfect fit for Heupel’s offense, the program has shown that it can function well within the system even without a superstar quarterback. Last season, Tennessee’s offense ranked among the top in the nation in total yards and points per game, and much of that success came from the development of quarterback Hendon Hooker. Hooker, who was not a highly touted recruit coming out of high school, was able to thrive under Heupel’s system, leading Tennessee to one of its best seasons in years.
Heupel’s ability to develop quarterbacks is one of the main reasons McElroy remains optimistic about Tennessee’s future. Whether it’s Joe Milton, the likely starter for the upcoming season, or another quarterback who steps into the role, Heupel’s system gives Tennessee a chance to succeed no matter who is under center.
2. A Talented Roster Beyond Quarterback
While Iamaleava’s departure is certainly a setback, it doesn’t take away from the overall talent on the Tennessee roster. The Vols are stacked with playmakers on both sides of the ball, including several skill position players who can make a big impact. The wide receiver room, for example, is deep with talent, featuring players like Jalin Hyatt, who is coming off a breakout season, and other emerging stars who can stretch the field vertically.
Tennessee’s offensive line has also shown significant improvement under Heupel, and the running back position has some talented players who can create big plays. All of these factors give the Vols the ability to continue running a dynamic offense, regardless of who plays quarterback. In fact, many believe that a quarterback like Joe Milton, who possesses a powerful arm, could excel in Heupel’s system, particularly with the weapons surrounding him.
On defense, Tennessee has made strides as well. While the defense still has room for improvement, there are several key players who could step up and contribute to the team’s success. The Volunteers have a solid defensive line, linebackers who are capable of making plays, and a secondary that, with development, could become a strength.
3. Recruiting Momentum
Despite Iamaleava’s departure, Tennessee’s recruiting efforts remain strong. The Volunteers have built a strong foundation on the recruiting trail, with Heupel and his staff bringing in talented players at key positions. Tennessee’s class for 2024 looks strong, with several highly ranked players committed to the program, including offensive linemen, defensive backs, and wide receivers. The Vols have also made inroads in the transfer portal, adding experienced players who can make an immediate impact.
The ability to recruit at a high level is one of the reasons McElroy believes Tennessee will remain competitive. While Iamaleava was a key part of the program’s future, Heupel’s ability to build a deep and talented roster means that Tennessee will continue to have the pieces necessary to compete in the SEC.
4. SEC Competition
The SEC, without a doubt, is one of the most competitive conferences in college football, but Tennessee is in a position to take advantage of its current standing. While Alabama, Georgia, and other traditional powers in the SEC will always be formidable, Tennessee’s success under Heupel has shown that the program is capable of competing at the highest level.
Tennessee has already shown it can hang with the top teams in the conference. The Vols had a huge win over Alabama in 2022, a victory that was celebrated as a defining moment for the program. With Heupel leading the charge, Tennessee’s high-scoring offense can give any team in the SEC fits. Even without Iamaleava, the Vols are equipped to contend for top spots in the SEC East.
The Quarterback Situation: Joe Milton’s Opportunity
The big question moving forward is who will take over as the starting quarterback. With Iamaleava no longer in the fold, Joe Milton III appears to be the frontrunner for the starting role. Milton, a former Michigan transfer, has shown flashes of potential during his time at Tennessee, but he has struggled with consistency. However, in Heupel’s system, Milton’s strong arm and ability to make plays down the field could be an asset.
Milton’s development will be key to Tennessee’s success in 2023. If he can adjust to Heupel’s fast-paced offense and become more consistent in his decision-making, the Vols have the potential to remain one of the most dangerous teams in the SEC. The talent around him, including a high-powered receiving corps and a solid offensive line, should help Milton thrive.
While the departure of Nico Iamaleava was undoubtedly a setback for Tennessee, Greg McElroy’s confidence in the program is well-placed. The foundation that Josh Heupel has built in Knoxville is strong, and the Vols are in “win-now mode” despite the loss of one player. With a dynamic offense, talented roster, and a head coach who has proven he can develop quarterbacks, Tennessee remains a formidable force in the SEC. The Volunteers are positioned to continue competing at a high level, and the future remains bright for this program.