The battle for Ohio State to replace its starting quarterback is still very close between Julian Sayin and Lincoln Kienholz
As the Ohio State Buckeyes prepare for the 2025 college football season, the competition to determine the starting quarterback has garnered significant attention. The primary contenders for the position are redshirt sophomore Lincoln Kienholz and redshirt freshman Julian Sayin, with true freshman Tavien St. Clair also entering the mix. Head coach Ryan Day has characterized the competition as “wide open,” emphasizing the intensity and openness of the battle ahead.
Lincoln Kienholz: The Veteran Competitor
Lincoln Kienholz, entering his third year with the Buckeyes, brings a level of experience to the quarterback room. Despite limited playing time in his first two seasons—appearing in three games as a freshman and one series during his sophomore year—Kienholz has been dedicated to his development. He has increased his weight from 185 to 212 pounds, enhancing his physical presence on the field. Kienholz describes his strengths as including athleticism, scrambling ability, and consistency in executing routine plays.
Acknowledging his role as the most seasoned member of the quarterback group, Kienholz has embraced a leadership position. He aims to be a reliable figure for his teammates, especially in high-pressure situations. Reflecting on the competition, Kienholz stated, “It feels wide open. It feels good because I come to the building every day and strive to be the best quarterback in the nation.”
Julian Sayin: The Promising Talent
Julian Sayin, a highly touted recruit from the 2024 class, transferred to Ohio State following the retirement of Alabama’s Nick Saban. As a freshman, Sayin served as the third-string quarterback, completing 5 of 12 passes for 84 yards and a touchdown. His rapid adaptation to the Buckeyes’ offensive system has been noted, with Sayin crediting the coaching staff for facilitating his learning process.
Sayin’s quick release and decision-making abilities have drawn praise, positioning him as a strong candidate for the starting role. Despite his limited collegiate experience, his potential has generated excitement among coaches and analysts alike.
Tavien St. Clair: The Freshman Contender
Adding to the competition is true freshman Tavien St. Clair, a five-star recruit from the 2025 class. Although he is the least experienced of the trio, St. Clair’s talent and potential cannot be overlooked. His performance during spring practices will be closely monitored as he seeks to make an impression on the coaching staff.
Coaching Perspectives and Expectations
Head coach Ryan Day has articulated clear expectations for the quarterbacks, emphasizing the importance of work ethic and leadership. He stated, “The No. 1 job for the quarterback is being the hardest-working guy in the building. There shouldn’t be any questions… They should be the first one in the building and the last one to leave.”
Quarterbacks coach Billy Fessler has observed growth in Kienholz’s understanding of the offense, noting improvements in areas such as eye discipline and timing. These developments are crucial as Kienholz competes for the starting position.
Potential Outcomes and Implications
The outcome of this quarterback competition will significantly influence the Buckeyes’ offensive strategy for the upcoming season. Should Sayin secure the starting role, his quick release and decision-making could lead to a dynamic passing game. Conversely, if Kienholz emerges as the starter, his athleticism and experience may provide a balanced offensive approach. St. Clair, while a long shot for the starting position, represents the future of the program and could benefit from developmental opportunities this season.
The competition also has implications for team dynamics and leadership. The starting quarterback often serves as a central figure in team morale and cohesion. Therefore, the decision will extend beyond on-field performance to include considerations of leadership qualities and the ability to inspire teammates.
As the Buckeyes progress through spring practices and into preseason camp, the coaching staff will continue to evaluate each quarterback’s performance, leadership, and fit within the offensive scheme. The decision will be pivotal in shaping Ohio State’s pursuit of success in the 2025 season.
