Kirby Smart’s Georgia Bulldogs will be college football’s top dog despite losing massive talent, says analyst.

College football is a dynamic sport where teams rise and fall from year to year, with programs constantly striving to maintain dominance amidst waves of talent changes and shifting dynamics. In this ever-changing landscape, one program that has firmly established itself at the pinnacle of the sport in recent years is the University of Georgia. Under the leadership of head coach Kirby Smart, the Georgia Bulldogs have become the model of consistency, winning back-to-back national championships in 2021 and 2022 and producing an array of elite talent that has left its mark on the NFL Draft.
However, with each new season comes inevitable roster turnover. The Bulldogs’ recent dominance has been built on a foundation of incredible talent, particularly in areas like defense, where Georgia has produced some of the best college football players in the country. As a result, following a season where Georgia saw a number of key players depart for the NFL, many observers have wondered whether the Bulldogs can continue their reign atop college football. Despite the substantial talent exodus, analysts remain bullish on Georgia’s future, citing several key reasons why the Bulldogs will continue to be a dominant force under Kirby Smart’s leadership.
A Legacy of Excellence Under Kirby Smart
Since taking the helm in 2016, Kirby Smart has turned Georgia into a juggernaut in college football. With a heavy emphasis on recruiting elite talent, building a powerful and disciplined defense, and establishing a balanced offensive attack, Smart has built Georgia into one of the most consistent and successful programs in the country.
Smart’s recruiting classes have consistently ranked among the best in the nation, and his development of players has been nothing short of impressive. Georgia’s ability to churn out NFL-ready talent, particularly on the defensive side of the ball, has been a key part of their success. Under Smart, Georgia’s defense has been described as “NFL-ready,” a testament to the coaching staff’s ability to develop players to the highest standard.
Despite losing several high-profile players to the NFL Draft, including key defensive stars like Jalen Carter, Nolan Smith, and Kelee Ringo, analysts are confident that Georgia will continue to be a force in college football. Smart has consistently recruited at an elite level, and the Bulldogs have a wealth of young, talented players ready to step into prominent roles.
The “Next Man Up” Mentality: Depth and Development
One of the defining characteristics of Kirby Smart’s Georgia program is its depth. While many teams across college football can be devastated by the loss of top-tier talent, Georgia’s ability to reload rather than rebuild is what has set it apart. The Bulldogs have cultivated a culture of competition, where the next man up mentality is not just encouraged but expected.
This depth is especially noticeable on the defensive side of the ball. Georgia has been known for its defensive line strength, and while players like Jalen Carter have left for the NFL, the program has a pipeline of talent ready to step in and make an impact. Analysts point to players like Mykel Williams, a rising star on the defensive line, as someone who could fill the void left by Carter’s departure. Williams, who impressed in his freshman season, has the potential to become one of the best pass rushers in the country. Alongside other young defensive players like defensive back Malaki Starks and linebacker Smael Mondon, the Bulldogs’ defense remains one of the most feared in college football, even after the departure of so many key contributors.
Georgia’s ability to seamlessly integrate young talent into their lineup has become a hallmark of the program under Smart. While many teams may falter after losing multiple first-round draft picks, Georgia’s culture ensures that incoming players are not only physically ready to compete at a high level, but mentally prepared as well. With a deep roster and a relentless work ethic instilled by Smart, Georgia remains a team that can plug in new players without skipping a beat.
Elite Recruiting: The Key to Sustained Success
Recruiting has been the cornerstone of Kirby Smart’s success at Georgia. Under his leadership, Georgia has consistently finished with top-ranked recruiting classes, including the number one class in the nation in 2023. This pipeline of elite talent has been the backbone of Georgia’s recent dominance, and it shows no signs of slowing down.
While the Bulldogs have lost several star players to the NFL, their recruiting efforts ensure that they will continue to be stocked with top-tier talent. In addition to Mykel Williams, other players who could see expanded roles in 2024 include wide receiver Dillon Bell, running back Branson Robinson, and offensive lineman Amarius Mims. These young players, along with the influx of new recruits, will ensure that Georgia remains competitive at the highest level.
Georgia’s recruiting success is not just about bringing in five-star players—it’s about building a program that fosters growth and development. Smart and his coaching staff have built a reputation for not only identifying talent but for maximizing the potential of that talent. Whether it’s through position coaching, player development, or scheme adjustments, Georgia’s program has consistently produced NFL-ready players, and that will continue to be the case moving forward.
Moreover, the Bulldogs’ ability to recruit nationally has given them access to a wide pool of talent from all over the country. Players from all corners of the U.S. have chosen to come to Georgia, attracted by the program’s success, the chance to play in the SEC, and the opportunity to develop under Smart’s coaching staff. This diversity in recruiting has allowed Georgia to build a well-rounded team that can excel in all areas of the game, from the offensive line to the secondary, and everywhere in between.
Offensive Evolution: The Rise of Carson Beck
While Georgia has long been known for its suffocating defense, the Bulldogs’ offense has also been evolving under Smart. The loss of quarterback Stetson Bennett, who led the Bulldogs to back-to-back national championships, leaves a significant hole at the most important position on the field. However, analysts remain confident that Georgia’s offense will remain potent with the emergence of Carson Beck as the new starting quarterback.
Beck, who has served as Bennett’s backup for the past couple of seasons, has been highly regarded for his arm strength, accuracy, and leadership qualities. Analysts point to his performance in limited action over the past two seasons as an indicator that he is ready to take the reins of the offense. With weapons like wide receiver Ladd McConkey, tight end Brock Bowers, and running back Kendall Milton, Beck will have the tools necessary to thrive.
Georgia’s offensive line, which has consistently been one of the best in the nation, will also play a crucial role in ensuring that Beck has the time and protection he needs to succeed. The Bulldogs have a stable of running backs, including Milton and Robinson, who can help control the game on the ground, providing balance to the offense. This balanced attack will take some of the pressure off Beck, allowing him to develop as a quarterback while still being supported by a powerful running game.
While there may be some growing pains as Beck adjusts to being the full-time starter, analysts believe that the combination of Beck’s potential and Georgia’s offensive system will allow the Bulldogs to remain one of the most potent offenses in college football.
The Georgia Bulldogs’ Culture: A Winning Mentality
Perhaps the most important factor in Georgia’s continued dominance is the culture that Kirby Smart has cultivated within the program. Smart has created an environment where winning is expected, and mediocrity is not tolerated. This culture permeates every aspect of the program, from recruitment to player development to game preparation. Georgia’s players understand that they are held to the highest standards, and they are motivated to maintain the program’s success.
This mindset has become ingrained in the team’s DNA. The Bulldogs are relentless in their pursuit of excellence, and every player is expected to contribute to the team’s success, regardless of their age or experience level. The culture of competition and accountability ensures that Georgia will continue to develop players who are capable of stepping in and making an immediate impact when needed.
Under Smart’s leadership, Georgia has built a foundation that will continue to pay dividends for years to come. The Bulldogs are not just a flash in the pan—they are a program that is built to sustain success over the long haul.