The Ohio State quarterback is regularly compared to a former Buckeyes standout.

The Ohio State University football program has long been known for producing some of the best quarterbacks in college football history. From legends like Troy Smith to Justin Fields, the Buckeyes have boasted a rich tradition of elite signal-callers who have gone on to have successful careers in both college football and the NFL. However, as Ohio State’s quarterback situation evolves, one player has recently emerged, drawing significant attention and praise. The comparisons to a former Buckeye standout have become inevitable, with many analysts and fans alike drawing parallels between the two quarterbacks.

This year’s Ohio State quarterback, CJ Stroud, has quickly become a rising star in the college football world. Not only is Stroud one of the most highly regarded quarterbacks in the nation, but he has also garnered frequent comparisons to a former Buckeye great: Justin Fields. Fields, who played for Ohio State from 2019 to 2020, is widely regarded as one of the most electrifying quarterbacks to ever play for the Buckeyes. His success both at Ohio State and in the NFL with the Chicago Bears makes him an iconic figure in Buckeye football history.

So, why do analysts and fans alike regularly compare CJ Stroud to Justin Fields? Is it simply because both players are Ohio State quarterbacks, or is there something more to these comparisons? In this article, we’ll delve into the reasons behind these comparisons, examining their playing styles, accomplishments, and the unique qualities that both quarterbacks bring to the table.

CJ Stroud: The Rise of a Star

CJ Stroud’s rise to prominence as Ohio State’s starting quarterback is nothing short of impressive. Stroud began his career as a backup to former quarterback Justin Fields, but after Fields left for the NFL, Stroud took the reins in 2021 and quickly became one of the top quarterbacks in the country. His 2021 season was a breakout year, with Stroud throwing for over 4,400 yards, 44 touchdowns, and just 6 interceptions. His combination of arm strength, poise, and football IQ made him an instant success in the Big Ten and a legitimate contender for the Heisman Trophy.

Stroud’s ability to distribute the ball to Ohio State’s elite receiving corps, which included Garrett Wilson, Chris Olave, and Jaxon Smith-Njigba, further elevated his status. His command of the offense, deep ball accuracy, and calm demeanor in pressure situations earned him the respect of coaches, scouts, and fans alike.

In 2022, Stroud’s success continued, leading Ohio State to a national championship game appearance. His ability to read defenses, manage the game, and stay composed in crucial moments allowed the Buckeyes to compete at the highest level. Stroud’s passing statistics, decision-making, and ability to make every throw on the field have solidified his status as one of the top quarterbacks in college football.

But despite all his success, there remains one significant shadow hovering over Stroud’s career: the shadow of Justin Fields.

Justin Fields: A Buckeyes Icon

Before Stroud took the helm at Ohio State, Justin Fields was the face of the program for two seasons. Fields transferred to Ohio State from Georgia in 2019 and immediately became one of the best quarterbacks in college football. His dynamic dual-threat ability, combined with his physical tools, quickly made him a household name. Fields was known for his rocket arm, precision passing, and ability to make plays with his legs when necessary.

Fields’ 2019 season was nothing short of spectacular. He threw for 3,273 yards, 41 touchdowns, and just 3 interceptions, leading Ohio State to a 13-0 regular season record and an appearance in the College Football Playoff (CFP). Fields demonstrated a combination of deep passing accuracy, quick decision-making, and the ability to read defenses that set him apart from other quarterbacks in the nation. However, it was his ability to extend plays with his legs that earned him the title of dual-threat quarterback.

In the 2020 season, Fields led Ohio State to a Big Ten Championship and another CFP appearance. He threw for over 2,100 yards, 22 touchdowns, and just 6 interceptions in a shortened season due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Fields was known for his leadership, toughness, and ability to rise to the occasion in big moments, particularly in Ohio State’s playoff victory over Clemson. His performance in that game, which included a tough hit that left him injured but still managing to lead the Buckeyes to victory, became legendary among Ohio State fans.

Fields’ success at Ohio State made him a top pick in the 2021 NFL Draft, where the Chicago Bears selected him with the 11th overall pick. While his NFL career has had ups and downs, Fields remains one of the most iconic players in Ohio State football history. His unique skill set and leadership qualities have set a standard for future Buckeyes quarterbacks.

The Comparison: Why Stroud and Fields Are Often Compared

At first glance, it may seem like Stroud and Fields are different types of quarterbacks, but a closer look reveals numerous similarities that have led to the ongoing comparisons between the two. Some of the key factors that have driven these comparisons include:

1. Elite Physical Tools

Both Stroud and Fields are incredibly talented quarterbacks with elite physical tools. Stroud, while not a dual-threat quarterback like Fields, has the arm strength, accuracy, and poise that have made him one of the best pure passers in college football. Fields, on the other hand, had a much more mobile and dynamic playing style, capable of making spectacular runs with his legs in addition to his strong arm.

While Stroud may not have Fields’ elite rushing ability, he has demonstrated his own level of athleticism, evading pressure in the pocket and making key runs when necessary. Stroud’s mobility, while not as flashy as Fields’, allows him to extend plays and keep defenses honest. Fields, with his ability to scramble and make plays on the move, was a more dangerous running threat.

Despite their differences in playing style, both quarterbacks excel at making all the necessary throws—whether it’s a deep bomb down the sideline, a tight-window throw in the red zone, or a quick slant across the middle. Both quarterbacks have shown the ability to read defenses, go through progressions, and make decisions on the fly.

2. Success in Ohio State’s Offensive System

Both Stroud and Fields thrived in Ohio State’s high-powered offensive system. The Buckeyes have long been known for their ability to put up points, and both quarterbacks benefited from an offense that emphasized spreading the field, utilizing elite talent at wide receiver, and attacking downfield.

Stroud’s success came as a direct result of his ability to read defenses and work within head coach Ryan Day’s system. Stroud has shown a calmness in the pocket and an ability to quickly make decisions when pressured. He has been the perfect fit for Day’s offense, which is predicated on precise passing, tempo, and high-scoring play.

Similarly, Fields benefited from Ohio State’s offensive system, but he also brought an added element of mobility and playmaking. Fields’ dual-threat ability kept defenses on their toes, and he had the freedom to make plays outside the structure of the offense. Fields’ success at Ohio State was a testament to his ability to thrive in a modern, fast-paced offensive system while also utilizing his mobility as a weapon.

3. Leadership and Toughness

Both Stroud and Fields have shown exceptional leadership on and off the field. Fields’ leadership in the 2020 College Football Playoff against Clemson, despite taking a hard hit and playing through pain, left an indelible mark on Ohio State football fans. His willingness to fight through adversity was one of the defining traits of his career.

Stroud, too, has shown remarkable leadership. In 2022, when Ohio State faced Michigan in a crucial late-season matchup, Stroud led the team with poise and confidence. His performance in big games, like the CFP appearances, has further cemented his status as a leader. Both players have handled the pressure of being Ohio State’s quarterback with grace, which is a testament to their mental toughness and preparation.

4. NFL Draft Buzz

Both Stroud and Fields have generated significant buzz heading into their respective NFL Draft years. Fields’ success at Ohio State made him a top-15 pick in the 2021 NFL Draft, while Stroud has positioned himself as one of the top quarterbacks in the 2025 draft class. The comparisons between the two stem from the fact that they are both elite quarterbacks in a program known for producing top-tier NFL talent. While Fields was known for his dual-threat ability and leadership, Stroud’s accuracy, poise, and pure passing ability have given him an edge as a pocket passer.

5. The Future of Ohio State Quarterbacks

Ohio State has established a reputation for producing top-notch quarterbacks, and Stroud and Fields are two of the most recent in that long line of talent. The comparisons between the two reflect the high expectations placed on Ohio State quarterbacks. As Stroud prepares to enter the NFL, the comparisons to Fields will continue, especially if Stroud goes on to enjoy similar success at the professional level.

 Stroud and Fields – Two Buckeyes, One Legacy

The comparisons between CJ Stroud and Justin Fields are a natural part of the narrative surrounding Ohio State football. Both players have made their mark on the program in their unique ways, with Fields leaving a legacy as a dual-threat quarterback and Stroud setting the standard for precise, powerful passing. Though they may differ in style, both quarterbacks have contributed to Ohio State’s continued dominance and success on the national stage.

As Stroud prepares for his future in the NFL, it is clear that he and Fields have more in common than just their time at Ohio State. Both players have shown the ability to lead, excel in high-pressure situations, and bring a unique skill set to their respective teams. Whether Stroud follows in Fields’ footsteps to the NFL or carves out his own path, one thing is certain: the legacy of Ohio State quarterbacks is in good hands.