According to a national commentator, Alabama football coach Kalen DeBoer will probably lose his job if he doesn’t do one thing.

In the cutthroat world of college football, few programs can claim the level of success and scrutiny that Alabama football has long enjoyed. The Crimson Tide, led by legendary head coach Nick Saban, have been a dominant force in college football for over a decade. However, in recent seasons, the landscape of the sport has shifted slightly, and new faces are beginning to emerge in key coaching roles.

One such figure is Kalen DeBoer, who has recently taken on the challenge of rejuvenating Alabama’s offense. The pressure is immense, and DeBoer finds himself under a microscope from the media, fans, and fellow coaches. With expectations high and the Crimson Tide hoping to maintain their place among college football’s elite, DeBoer’s tenure is already being discussed in national circles. Some commentators are suggesting that DeBoer’s future at Alabama could hinge on one crucial factor, and if he doesn’t deliver, he may find himself out of a job.

The Alabama Football Dynasty and the Need for Change

Alabama has built its success over the last decade largely through a powerful, defense-first mentality under Nick Saban’s leadership. The defense has been the foundation of Alabama’s dominance, producing numerous first-round NFL draft picks and holding some of the best offenses in the country to single-digit scores. However, in recent years, the need for a more dynamic offensive approach has become increasingly apparent. Alabama’s offense has not kept pace with the high-powered offenses of rivals like LSU, Clemson, and Ohio State.

Despite having one of the most talented rosters in college football, Alabama’s offense has faced challenges in recent seasons, particularly at the quarterback position. Saban’s reliance on a traditional, pro-style offense has been somewhat limiting in an era that increasingly favors up-tempo, spread, and dynamic passing schemes. As a result, many believe that a fresh offensive philosophy is required to ensure that Alabama remains competitive with the best teams in college football.

DeBoer, a rising star in coaching circles, was brought in to help implement these changes. His background includes successful stints as an offensive coordinator at Fresno State, where he turned around a program and produced one of the most efficient offenses in the country. His success at the Group of Five level quickly garnered attention from Power Five programs, and it wasn’t long before he was considered a top candidate to take over Alabama’s offense.

However, with great opportunity comes great pressure. DeBoer’s hiring has been met with high expectations, and Alabama’s offense must improve dramatically if the Crimson Tide are to stay on top of the SEC and contend for national championships. Some analysts believe that DeBoer is walking a fine line, and the future of his tenure in Tuscaloosa could depend on one key factor.

The National Commentator’s Warning: “Do One Thing or He’s Gone”

National commentators have been quick to offer their thoughts on DeBoer’s job security, with many emphasizing the stakes of the situation. A prominent sports analyst recently made waves by declaring that Kalen DeBoer’s future at Alabama is uncertain unless he delivers on one very specific goal: quarterback development.

DeBoer is widely regarded for his ability to build efficient and explosive offenses, but Alabama’s most pressing need is in the quarterback room. The Crimson Tide have recruited elite quarterbacks, but the position has been a revolving door in recent seasons, with no one player stepping up and securing the starting job for the long term. Quarterback play has been a key concern, and Alabama needs to find stability at the position in order to return to championship contention.

The national commentator argued that if DeBoer cannot develop a consistent, top-tier quarterback at Alabama, he will likely lose his job. With the resources at Alabama’s disposal, it’s expected that the Tide will have access to some of the best quarterbacks in the country, but those quarterbacks need to be developed effectively in order to maximize the offense’s potential. If DeBoer cannot make this happen, his tenure could be short-lived.

The pressure is even higher considering Alabama’s recent struggles in the quarterback department. In 2023, the Crimson Tide started two quarterbacks, Jalen Milroe and Ty Simpson, neither of whom could fully seize the role and lead the offense with confidence. This inconsistency at quarterback has raised doubts about the team’s ability to compete with high-octane offenses like those of Georgia, Ohio State, and LSU. Alabama’s defense remains as strong as ever, but without a reliable quarterback to lead the offense, the team’s chances of winning another national championship will be severely hampered.

The Quarterback Dilemma: A Critical Issue for DeBoer

The importance of the quarterback position in college football cannot be overstated. A great quarterback can elevate the entire team, making even the most basic plays look spectacular. On the flip side, inconsistent quarterback play can derail an offense, leaving even the most talented skill players in the lurch. Alabama has seen both ends of this spectrum in recent years, and it’s clear that finding a solution at quarterback is DeBoer’s most pressing challenge.

DeBoer’s reputation as a quarterback guru is well-earned. At Fresno State, he helped develop talented quarterbacks like Jake Haener, who became one of the best passers in college football during his time under DeBoer. If DeBoer can replicate this success at Alabama, he could quickly earn the trust of the fanbase and coaching staff. However, if he is unable to mold a quarterback into a dynamic, playmaking leader, the pressure will mount, and the calls for his firing will grow louder.

Several quarterbacks are vying for the starting role at Alabama heading into the 2025 season. Jalen Milroe, who showed flashes of brilliance in 2023, remains a contender, but his inconsistency has been a point of concern. Ty Simpson, a highly-touted recruit, has the talent to lead Alabama, but he has yet to prove himself on the field in a significant way. DeBoer’s ability to develop one of these quarterbacks into a reliable and dynamic playmaker will go a long way in determining his future in Tuscaloosa.

Additionally, Alabama has been active in recruiting top quarterback prospects for the 2026 class, and DeBoer’s ability to build a relationship with these recruits will be critical. The Crimson Tide’s success on the recruiting trail is one of the program’s greatest assets, but those recruits must feel confident that DeBoer will be able to develop them into NFL-caliber quarterbacks.

The Stakes: Alabama’s High Expectations

Alabama’s success under Nick Saban has set a standard that is difficult to match. The Crimson Tide have won multiple national championships and have remained a consistent contender throughout Saban’s tenure. However, with the SEC growing stronger and more competitive, Alabama can no longer afford to be complacent. The program must continue to evolve, and that means addressing its offensive issues.

Kalen DeBoer’s offensive philosophy is seen as the key to bringing Alabama’s offense into the modern era. He has the experience and the pedigree to succeed, but if he cannot figure out the quarterback situation, he will be at risk of losing his job. Alabama has the resources, the talent, and the support to be successful, but ultimately, it all comes down to one thing: developing a quarterback who can lead the team back to a national championship.

In an era where high-powered offenses are crucial to success, Alabama cannot afford to fall behind. Saban’s defense will always be a strength, but the offense must match the level of play on the other side of the ball. DeBoer’s task is clear—he must develop a quarterback who can run the offense efficiently and put up points when it matters most.