Analyst: The Bears should trade a former Texas A&M standout for a young Pro Bowl quarterback.

The Chicago Bears are in a critical phase of their rebuilding process. After years of underperformance and instability at key positions, the organization faces a decision that could shape its future for years to come. For the Bears to become legitimate Super Bowl contenders, they need to put together a roster capable of contending in the modern NFL—one that revolves around elite quarterback play. While Justin Fields has shown flashes of potential, his development remains inconsistent, and the Bears’ front office has to decide whether to double down on their young quarterback or pursue a better, more established signal-caller.

In an intriguing analysis, some experts have begun to suggest that the Bears should consider trading one of their current assets—a former Texas A&M standout—for a young, Pro Bowl quarterback. This move could bring the Bears closer to immediate relevance and drastically change the trajectory of their rebuild. But how realistic is this idea, and would such a trade truly benefit the Bears in the long term? Let’s take a deep dive into this analysis, focusing on the rationale behind the trade, the player in question, and the possible scenarios for a trade involving a Pro Bowl quarterback.

The Bears’ Current Quarterback Situation

As of 2025, Justin Fields remains the starting quarterback for the Bears. Fields, drafted in 2021, has shown moments of brilliance but has struggled with consistency. His combination of athleticism and arm strength gives him the potential to be a dynamic force in the NFL, but issues with decision-making, accuracy, and passing mechanics have hindered his ability to fully reach his ceiling.

The Bears have invested heavily in Fields, but at this stage of his development, they must ask themselves a critical question: Can Fields be the quarterback who leads them to championship contention? While his upside is undeniable, his lack of consistency in key games has led some analysts to question whether his developmental curve will ever smooth out, or if the Bears should move on and pursue a more polished, proven quarterback.

At this juncture, the Bears may feel they need a quarterback who can immediately elevate the offense and, in turn, accelerate the rebuilding process. A Pro Bowl-caliber quarterback would provide the type of stability and high-level performance necessary for the Bears to compete at the highest level.

Why Trade a Former Texas A&M Standout?

One of the potential assets the Bears could leverage in a trade for a young Pro Bowl quarterback is defensive standout DeMarvion Overshown, a former Texas A&M Aggie who has made a name for himself as a versatile linebacker. Overshown, known for his athleticism, speed, and high football IQ, has the potential to become one of the league’s best defensive players. His ability to cover ground quickly, disrupt plays in the backfield, and rush the passer makes him a valuable asset for any team.

However, despite Overshown’s immense talent, the Bears may feel that they can afford to move on from him, especially if doing so could land them a top-tier quarterback. The NFL is, at its core, a quarterback-driven league, and the Bears may be willing to part with a young, talented linebacker if it means bringing in a proven quarterback who could instantly improve their offense.

By trading Overshown, the Bears would be acknowledging that, while defense is important, success in today’s NFL requires an elite quarterback. Offense is the currency of the modern league, and the Bears, despite having an improving defense, need to solidify their offensive identity to compete consistently.

What Would It Take to Land a Young Pro Bowl Quarterback?

To land a young Pro Bowl quarterback, the Bears would likely need to part with a significant amount of capital. Trading for a quarterback of this caliber is no small feat, and Chicago would have to offer both established talent and draft picks. Given that Overshown is a rising star on defense, his trade value could be substantial, but it will depend on several factors, including the potential quarterback’s age, contract situation, and performance.

For example, the Bears might look to target quarterbacks who are under 25 and have already earned Pro Bowl selections. These players represent a “next-generation” quarterback who has already proven their worth at the NFL level but is still young enough to lead a team for a decade or more. Some quarterbacks in this category include:

1. Justin Herbert (Los Angeles Chargers)

Herbert has quickly established himself as one of the NFL’s top quarterbacks. Known for his rocket arm, ability to make all the throws, and leadership, Herbert is an ideal candidate for a team like the Bears that is looking for a long-term solution at quarterback. If the Chargers were ever to entertain the idea of moving Herbert (due to salary cap concerns or a desire for a fresh start), the Bears could make a compelling offer, including Overshown and multiple draft picks.

2. Jalen Hurts (Philadelphia Eagles)

Hurts is another young quarterback who has impressed in his short time as a starter. After leading the Eagles to the Super Bowl in 2024, Hurts has proven he can win games with his arm and his legs. While the Eagles are unlikely to move on from him, his availability would cause a frenzy around the league. If the Eagles were ever to consider trading Hurts, a team like the Bears, armed with talent like Overshown, would likely be one of the front-runners to acquire him.

3. Tua Tagovailoa (Miami Dolphins)

Tua has emerged as one of the league’s most accurate passers and is the leader of one of the NFL’s most explosive offenses. Although the Dolphins have built their offense around Tua’s unique skill set, the Bears could still consider targeting him if they believe his development trajectory aligns with their long-term goals. If Miami ever decided to move on from Tua, the Bears could offer Overshown, along with additional draft capital, to land him.

How Could a Young Pro Bowl Quarterback Elevate the Bears?

Adding a young, proven quarterback would be a game-changer for the Bears. The team’s success over the past few years has largely been marred by poor quarterback play, which has undermined their overall progress. With a new quarterback in place, the Bears would be able to immediately upgrade their offense and increase their chances of winning now.

1. Stability at the Quarterback Position

A young Pro Bowl quarterback would bring immediate stability to the Bears’ offense. No longer would they have to worry about the inconsistency that has plagued Fields’ tenure. The new quarterback would allow the offense to operate at a higher level, leading to better overall team performance and an increased likelihood of winning games. Stability at quarterback would also provide a much-needed boost to the Bears’ skill position players, including the wide receivers and running backs.

2. Accelerating the Rebuild

The Bears have been in a rebuilding phase for years, but with a top-tier quarterback under center, the process could be fast-tracked. A young quarterback with Pro Bowl credentials would inject the team with an infusion of talent and leadership, helping them make the leap from a rebuilding team to a playoff contender.

3. Attracting Free Agents

Having a young, dynamic quarterback can also help the Bears attract other free agents. Top-tier talent wants to play with elite quarterbacks, and securing one would make the Bears a more desirable landing spot for players looking to join a competitive team.

4. Developing a Winning Culture

The Bears need to shift from a culture of mediocrity to one of sustained excellence. A young Pro Bowl quarterback would set the tone for the rest of the team, establishing an environment where winning becomes the expectation, not the exception. The new quarterback would not only elevate his own game but also inspire his teammates to perform at a higher level.

Trade Scenarios

If the Bears pursue a trade for a young Pro Bowl quarterback, they would likely have to make several different offers depending on the team and quarterback in question. Potential scenarios could include:

1. DeMarvion Overshown + 2025 First-Round Pick: If the Bears are targeting a quarterback like Herbert or Hurts, a combination of Overshown and a 2025 first-round pick would likely be a strong offer.
2. DeMarvion Overshown + 2026 Second-Round Pick + 2027 First-Round Pick: For a player like Tua or another top quarterback under contract for several more years, the Bears may need to offer additional picks to sweeten the deal.
3. Overshown + Established Bears Player: If a trade partner seeks a more immediate impact player, the Bears could consider including an established player, such as a veteran wide receiver or defensive back, alongside Overshown.