Analyzing the quarterback position for LSU football in light of previous events

The quarterback position at LSU football has been a focal point for several years now, and with the recent developments in the 2024 and 2025 seasons, there’s much to analyze as the Tigers look ahead. The quarterback is often the most scrutinized and celebrated player on the team, and LSU’s quest for consistency at the position has been a key narrative in its pursuit of national championships, SEC titles, and overall program prestige. Over the past few years, LSU has seen some highs and lows, but under the guidance of head coach Brian Kelly, there’s optimism about where the quarterback position stands.

In this article, we will delve into the state of LSU football’s quarterback position, focusing on the recent developments at the position, historical context, and how these events impact the future of LSU football.

Historical Context of LSU’s Quarterback Position

Historically, LSU football has been known for its dominant running game, solid defense, and the ability to recruit elite players at key positions, such as running back and defensive line. However, the quarterback position has not always been as stable or successful as other parts of the roster.

Throughout much of the 2000s and early 2010s, LSU’s quarterbacks often played second fiddle to the dominant ground game led by tailbacks like Leonard Fournette, Jeremy Hill, and others. As a result, LSU didn’t always have the high-profile signal-caller that other elite programs like Alabama or Ohio State were known for. Players like JaMarcus Russell (2003-2006), who went on to become the first overall pick in the 2007 NFL Draft, were exceptions to this trend.

From the mid-2000s to the 2010s, the Tigers had a revolving door at quarterback, featuring players such as Matt Flynn, Jordan Jefferson, Zach Mettenberger, and Danny Etling. While some of these quarterbacks had solid college careers, they never truly elevated LSU to a national title level through the air. The result was often LSU’s reliance on its defense and running game to carry the team to victories, which worked in some years, but ultimately kept the team from competing for national championships on a consistent basis.

Then came Joe Burrow in 2018, a game-changer who altered the trajectory of the LSU football program. Burrow’s performance in the 2019 season is widely regarded as one of the best in college football history. Under new offensive coordinator Joe Brady, Burrow led LSU to an undefeated season, an SEC Championship, and a national title. His success in Baton Rouge completely shifted LSU’s approach to the quarterback position, establishing LSU as a viable contender in both the SEC and national championship races with a high-powered passing game.

Despite Burrow’s historic rise to prominence, LSU has had to contend with a series of quarterback questions since his departure in 2020. The program’s search for stability at the position, following Burrow’s departure, has shaped much of the team’s strategy in recent seasons. But with head coach Brian Kelly at the helm since 2022, and his ability to recruit top-tier talent, LSU appears poised to regain its footing at quarterback and establish a new era under center.

The 2023-2024 Quarterback Situation: Jayden Daniels and the Transfer Portal

In 2023, LSU’s quarterback situation took a significant turn with the transfer of Jayden Daniels from Arizona State. A highly sought-after dual-threat quarterback, Daniels arrived at LSU with the hope of providing stability and dual-threat ability to the position after a few years of uncertainty.

Daniels’ impact on LSU football in 2023 was immediate. He was a key reason why LSU’s offense was able to remain competitive, even in a season marked by inconsistencies. His mobility and ability to make plays with his legs added a dimension to LSU’s offense that had been lacking in recent seasons. In his first season at LSU, Daniels threw for over 2,900 yards, rushed for 885 yards, and accounted for 27 total touchdowns. Despite some growing pains and inconsistency in key moments, Daniels gave the LSU offense a level of playmaking ability that had been missing for quite some time.

Daniels’ mobility was perhaps his most significant asset in 2023, as it allowed LSU to overcome some offensive line struggles and create opportunities on broken plays. However, it was his passing ability that continued to evolve under the guidance of offensive coordinator Mike Denbrock. While Daniels showed flashes of brilliance, his inconsistency in key games raised some questions about whether he could truly be the long-term answer for LSU at quarterback.

One of the most notable developments of 2023 was Daniels’ decision to return for the 2024 season, as he announced that he would forgo entering the NFL Draft and instead continue his college career at LSU. This decision was a major boost for the Tigers, as Daniels’ experience and dual-threat capabilities provided LSU with a proven quarterback to build around for the upcoming season. With Daniels back, LSU could focus on further developing its offense and building on the foundation set in 2023.

The 2024 Quarterback Battle: A Highly Competitive Field

As LSU enters the 2024 season, the quarterback position is once again a point of emphasis. With Jayden Daniels returning, many assumed that the competition for the starting job would be settled. However, the situation has become more complex with the addition of other talented quarterbacks, both from the transfer portal and the high school ranks.

1. Jayden Daniels – The Returning Starter

Daniels’ return to LSU provides a sense of continuity at the quarterback position. Having already experienced a full season in Baton Rouge, Daniels has a good understanding of LSU’s offensive system and the challenges that come with playing in the SEC. His experience and dual-threat ability make him the frontrunner to start for LSU in 2024. However, for LSU to take the next step as a championship contender, Daniels will need to improve in certain areas, such as his consistency as a passer, especially in critical moments during big games.

In 2023, LSU showed it could compete at a high level with Daniels at the helm, but the Tigers fell short in some important contests, including the SEC Championship Game and a loss to Texas A&M late in the season. While Daniels’ athleticism and playmaking ability were evident, LSU will need him to step up in the passing game, particularly in clutch situations, in order to reach its full potential in 2024.

2. The Transfer Portal Addition: Walker Howard

In addition to Daniels, LSU brought in another highly rated quarterback through the transfer portal in Walker Howard, a former top recruit from Louisiana who initially committed to Ole Miss. Howard’s decision to transfer to LSU added an interesting wrinkle to the quarterback competition. A prototypical pocket passer, Howard brings a different skill set to the table compared to Daniels. Howard’s arm strength, accuracy, and ability to make all the throws in the passing game make him an intriguing option for LSU’s offense.

While Howard will likely start his LSU career as a backup, his potential could lead to an intense quarterback competition in the future. If Daniels struggles to consistently perform at a high level, Howard could be given the opportunity to prove himself. LSU fans and coaches alike will be watching closely to see how Howard develops under the tutelage of offensive coordinator Mike Denbrock.

3. Garrett Nussmeier – The Wildcard

Garrett Nussmeier, another key quarterback for LSU in 2024, has become something of a wildcard in the quarterback competition. Nussmeier saw significant playing time during the 2023 season after Daniels dealt with some injuries. In those moments, Nussmeier showcased his arm talent and ability to make plays under pressure. However, he also displayed some inconsistency, with turnovers and erratic play leading to mixed results.

Nussmeier’s potential is undeniable, and many believe he could be the future of LSU’s quarterback position. If Daniels does not improve or if Howard struggles to adapt to LSU’s system, Nussmeier could seize the starting role and take full advantage of his natural talent. His competitiveness and ability to make throws downfield are qualities that make him an intriguing prospect for the Tigers.

The Future of LSU’s Quarterback Position: Building Toward the Future

Looking beyond the 2024 season, LSU’s quarterback position is in a solid spot, with several talented players on the roster. Jayden Daniels’ decision to return for one more year provides LSU with a proven option at quarterback, and his leadership will be key to LSU’s success. However, the emergence of young talent like Walker Howard and Garrett Nussmeier means that LSU has options moving forward.

In the coming seasons, LSU will continue to build its quarterback depth, and with Brian Kelly’s recruiting acumen, the Tigers are well-positioned to attract elite talent at the position. The competition for the starting job in 2024 and beyond will ensure that LSU has the right player under center to compete at the highest level.

As LSU looks to contend for national championships, the quarterback position will remain one of the most critical areas of focus. With talent and experience, LSU has the foundation to elevate its offense, and the quarterback battle in 2024 will be crucial in determining whether the Tigers can return to the top of the SEC and the College Football Playoff picture.